The 30 Worst Frozen Pizzas According to Shoppers

A shopper examines several disappointing-looking frozen pizzas on a kitchen counter.

Frozen pizza is one of the easiest dinners you can buy, but the freezer aisle is full of pies that look great on the box and disappoint on the plate. Shoppers, food writers and taste testers keep pointing to the same problems: cardboard crusts, bland or bitter sauce, rubbery cheese and toppings you can count on one hand.

This list gathers 30 frozen pizzas that shoppers and taste tests often rank at the bottom, from budget party pizzas to pricey premium pies. For each one you’ll find what people dislike about it and a better frozen pizza to buy instead.

1. Totino’s Triple Cheese Party Pizza

A small cheese pizza sits on a baking tray beside an open cardboard box.

Totino’s Party Pizza has been a cheap freezer staple for decades, and the Triple Cheese version regularly lands in last place when food writers line up frozen pizzas side by side. In one 10-pizza taste test it was called the worst of the bunch by a long shot, with its low price as its only real saving grace.

The complaints are consistent. Testers say the cheese is sparse, the sauce is overly sweet and the crust bakes up thin and airy rather than crisp or chewy. The whole pizza comes across as bland.

The cheese is also a sore point for label readers. The Totino’s product page lists imitation mozzarella, imitation Monterey Jack and imitation cheddar alongside rehydrated mozzarella, and that imitation cheese has stirred up controversy on social media more than once.

If you want a cheese pizza that actually tastes cheesy, spend a little more on DiGiorno Stuffed Crust Five Cheese, which finished well ahead of Totino’s in the same taste test.

2. Tony’s Pepperoni Pizza

A shopper looks unimpressed while inspecting a pepperoni pizza on a baking sheet.

Tony’s is one of the cheapest frozen pizzas in many grocery stores, and that low price is the main reason it ends up in carts. It is also why many shoppers walk away disappointed.

In a 10-pizza pepperoni taste test, Tony’s came in dead last. Testers said the crust was dry and crumbly, curling and cracking when they tried to cut it, and the cheese was spread far too thin. The verdict was that it tastes like exactly what it is: a cheap frozen pizza, nothing like a pizzeria pie.

Customer reviews of other Tony’s pizzas raise similar points. Shoppers who tried the Tony’s Supreme complain about skimpy toppings and a crust that turns rubbery as it cools.

For a small step up in price, Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni is a better pick. It placed near the top of the same test, with a crispier base.

3. Celeste Pizza for One Original

A small cheese pizza in a foil tray on a kitchen counter.

Celeste Pizza for One is a small, microwavable single-serve pizza aimed at anyone who wants a fast lunch for one. It is cheap, but it is also one of the most criticized frozen pizzas you can buy.

In one taste test, the testers gave up after just two bites. They said it tasted off, had a sticky consistency and compared it to a giant Bagel Bite that had lost its way. One-star reviews from shoppers point to the same problems: questionable cheese and a crust that turns mushy once it is heated.

The cheese complaints make sense when you read the box. Celeste’s Original 4 Cheese version uses an imitation mozzarella blend rather than only real cheese, which explains the processed taste many buyers notice.

If you want a quick pizza for one, try Amy’s Margherita Pizza, made with real mozzarella, or simply bake a slice or two of a better full-size frozen pizza and save the rest.

4. Kroger Pepperoni Classic Crust Pizza

A pepperoni pizza with a thick crust on a kitchen counter beside a plain food box.

Kroger’s store-brand pepperoni pizza is priced to beat the national brands, and it turns up on roundups of frozen pizzas with the worst customer reviews. The main complaint is simple: it is bland.

Reviewers say the pizza tastes plain, and some suggest you will need to add your own seasoning to give it any personality. That defeats the purpose of buying a ready-to-bake pizza.

Some shoppers are fine with it as a budget pie for kids, but if you want a pepperoni pizza that tastes good straight out of the box, it is not the one to grab. Kroger has other store-brand misses too, which we covered in our list of the worst Kroger products shoppers should think twice about.

A better choice is DiGiorno Premium Pepperoni Wood Fired Style Crust, which ranked in the top half of a 10-pizza pepperoni taste test.

5. Quest Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza

A thin-crust pepperoni pizza on a baking tray.

Quest makes this pizza for people who want high protein and fewer carbs, and the nutrition label is the main reason to buy it. The trade-off is the crust.

Because the crust is flourless, shoppers say it never gets truly crisp, and many describe the taste and texture as cardboard-like. Others say it is just average as a pizza and only makes sense if you are tracking macros closely.

Price is the other complaint. Each pizza is fairly small, and buyers often feel it costs a lot for what you get, especially if you need more than one to feel full.

If you want a lower-carb frozen pizza that tastes more like the real thing, try Real Good Foods chicken crust pizza or Cappello’s almond flour crust pizza. Cappello’s in particular has earned strong marks from food writers.

6. Jack’s Original Thin Crust Canadian Style Bacon Pizza

A thin-crust pizza topped with melted cheese and pieces of Canadian-style bacon.

Jack’s is a budget brand with a loyal following. The Canadian Style Bacon version, though, draws more than its share of complaints.

The biggest gripe is the topping that gives the pizza its name. Shoppers say the Canadian bacon comes in tiny chunks scattered across the pie, so you barely taste it. Reviewers also report that the crust can bake up hard or fall apart when you cut it.

It still works as a cheap snack, but if you buy it for the ham, you will likely feel shortchanged.

For a better thin crust from the same aisle, try DiGiorno Thin Crust Pepperoni, which ranked ahead of most of the field in an 11-pizza thin crust taste test.

7. Connie’s Sausage Classic Thin Crust Pizza

A thin-crust sausage pizza with sparse toppings rests on a tray near a grocery freezer aisle.

Connie’s is a Chicago pizzeria brand, and its frozen thin crust pizzas promise a crisp, thin slice. Many shoppers say the frozen version doesn’t live up to the name.

The most common complaint is the crust. Instead of baking up crisp, reviewers say it comes out limp and soggy, which takes away the main reason to buy a thin crust pizza in the first place. Some buyers also say the flavor is inconsistent from one box to the next, so a pizza you enjoyed once may taste different the next time.

If you try it anyway, bake it directly on the oven rack in a fully preheated oven to give the crust its best chance.

For a thin crust that reliably stays crisp, Screamin’ Sicilian Thin & Crispy Pepperoni was the top pick in an 11-pizza thin crust taste test.

8. Red Baron Meat Trio Stuffed Crust Pizza

A meat-topped pizza with a golden stuffed crust on a baking tray.

A pizza with three meats and a cheese-filled crust sounds like an easy win, but this Red Baron pie shows up on lists of frozen pizzas with poor customer reviews.

The stuffed crust is the problem. Shoppers say the cheese inside the crust turns grainy instead of stretchy, so the main selling point falls flat. The bottom of the crust gets criticism too, with reviewers comparing it to cardboard.

Some buyers like the amount of meat, but it can’t make up for a crust that disappoints at both the edge and the base.

If you want a stuffed crust pizza, DiGiorno Stuffed Crust Five Cheese is a better bet. Taste testers ranked it above most frozen pizzas, and their only wish was for even more cheese in the crust.

9. Freschetta Garlic Duo Savory Italian Sausage Pizza

A sausage and cheese pizza on a baking tray on a kitchen counter.

Freschetta’s Garlic Duo pizzas are sold on one idea: a big hit of garlic. According to shoppers, that is exactly where this sausage pizza falls short.

The most common complaint is that the garlic flavor is weak. Buyers who picked it up because they love garlic say it doesn’t deliver what the box promises. Without that garlic punch, it ends up as an ordinary sausage pizza.

If you still want to try it, a sprinkle of garlic powder or a drizzle of garlic oil before baking can help.

For a more satisfying pizza from a major brand, try Screamin’ Sicilian Holy Pepperoni, which taste testers praised for its sauce and plentiful pepperoni.

10. Stouffer’s French Bread Pepperoni Pizza

A pepperoni French bread pizza on a baking tray.

Stouffer’s French Bread Pizza is a nostalgic favorite for many shoppers, and you’ll find it in almost every grocery freezer. It also draws plenty of negative reviews.

The bread is the biggest issue. Reviewers say it is flavorless and often comes out soggy. The pepperoni gets criticism too: shoppers describe it as hard and greasy rather than crisp and spicy.

It is filling and easy, which is why it keeps selling, but many buyers say it isn’t as good as they remember.

If you like the French bread style, bake it in the oven rather than the microwave for a firmer base. For a better pizza overall, try Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni and enjoy a sturdier crust.

11. Good & Gather Self-Rising Crust Four Cheese Pizza

A thick-crust four-cheese pizza sits on a baking tray beside a plain pizza box.

Target’s Good & Gather self-rising pizza is meant to compete with name-brand rising crust pies at a lower price. Many shoppers say it doesn’t come close.

The crust gets the most complaints. Reviewers describe it as doughy and soggy. Some buyers also say they found the smell of the cheese unpleasant once the pizza came out of the oven, which is not what you want from a four cheese pie.

Store brands can be a good way to save, but this one leaves many buyers wishing they had paid a little more.

For a rising crust that holds up better, DiGiorno Original Rising Crust Four Cheese is the better choice. It is the best-known pizza in this style and easy to find in most grocery stores.

12. Member’s Mark Rising Crust Pepperoni Pizza

A pepperoni pizza with a thick rising crust on a kitchen counter.

Sam’s Club sells this store-brand pizza in multipacks, and the low price per pizza is the main attraction. Shoppers who stock their freezer with it often regret the bulk buy.

The crust is the top complaint. Reviewers say it is overly thick and chewy, so each bite is mostly bread. They also say there aren’t enough toppings to balance all that dough.

Some buyers think it is fine for feeding a crowd of kids, but if you want a pizza you’ll enjoy, the multipack savings may not be worth it.

A better rising crust option is DiGiorno Original Rising Crust Pepperoni, which many shoppers treat as the standard for this style.

13. Roma Original Pepperoni Thin Crust Pizza

A thin-crust pepperoni pizza sits on a baking tray.

Roma is a budget frozen pizza brand, and its pepperoni thin crust is one of the cheaper options in the case. Shoppers say you get what you pay for.

The crust is the main issue. Reviewers describe it as dry and hard rather than pleasantly crisp. Toppings are another complaint, with shoppers saying the pepperoni and cheese are spread sparsely across the pie.

A thin crust pizza with a dry base and few toppings has little left to offer.

For a better budget thin crust, try Jack’s Original Thin Crust Pepperoni. In an 11-pizza thin crust taste test, its only real flaw was a somewhat mild pepperoni.

14. Market Pantry Thin Crust Supreme Pizza

A thin-crust supreme pizza topped with pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onion, and melted cheese.

Market Pantry is Target’s budget store brand, and its thin crust supreme pizza looks loaded with toppings on the box. Shoppers say the taste doesn’t match the picture.

Reviewers say both the toppings and the crust are tasteless. They describe the crust as having a cardboard texture, and say the outer edge gets very hard once baked. With a supreme pizza, you expect a mix of meats and vegetables to bring plenty of flavor, so a bland result is a real letdown.

It may do in a pinch with extra seasoning, but it is hard to call it a pizza you’d look forward to.

For a supreme pizza with more flavor, DiGiorno Original Rising Crust Supreme is a widely available alternative with a softer, thicker crust.

15. Great Value Rising Crust Buffalo Style Chicken Pizza

A buffalo-style chicken pizza on a baking tray.

Walmart’s Great Value rising crust pizzas are some of the cheapest in the freezer aisle, and the Buffalo Style Chicken version stands out for its bad reviews.

Shoppers say it is over-salted and doesn’t have enough chicken to justify the name. Many also say the flavor misses the mark: instead of tangy buffalo sauce, it tastes more like spicy red pepper. If you love buffalo wings, this pizza is unlikely to scratch that itch.

It is not the only Great Value product that draws complaints. See our list of the worst Walmart Great Value products for more store-brand items shoppers say to skip.

For a chicken pizza with better reviews, try California Pizza Kitchen BBQ Recipe Chicken, one of the brand’s best-known frozen pizzas.

16. Red Baron Brick Oven Crust Cheese Trio Pizza

A cheese pizza with a thick crust on a baking tray.

Red Baron’s Brick Oven line is supposed to be a step up from its classic pizzas, with a crust meant to taste like it came from a brick oven. In one 10-pizza taste test, the Cheese Trio finished second to last.

The problem is the crust. The tester said the cheese and herb blend on top was decent, but the crust underneath was hard and cardboard-like, dragging the whole pizza down.

If you love the cheese on this pizza, you may be able to look past the crust, but it is a hard sell when better options sit in the same freezer case.

For a brick oven style cheese pizza with a much better crust, Rao’s Brick Oven Crust Five Cheese took the top spot in the same taste test.

17. Screamin’ Sicilian Bessie’s Revenge Pizza

A pepperoni pizza with a thick crust on a baking tray.

Screamin’ Sicilian has a strong reputation, and Bessie’s Revenge is its loaded cheese pizza. Not every taster thinks it lives up to the hype.

In one 10-pizza taste test it finished near the bottom. The tester said that despite all the cheese piled on top, the pizza tasted bland, and noted that it was one of the pricier pizzas in the lineup. Paying a premium for a pizza that doesn’t taste like much is hard to justify.

Fans still love the sheer amount of cheese, so this one depends on what you want. If flavor matters more than volume, you may be disappointed.

For a cheese pizza with more flavor, try DiGiorno Detroit-Style Crust Four Cheese, which ranked higher in the same test.

18. California Pizza Kitchen Four Cheese Crispy Thin Crust Pizza

A thin-crust four-cheese pizza on a round baking tray.

California Pizza Kitchen’s frozen pizzas carry a restaurant name and a higher price tag, so expectations are high. The Four Cheese Crispy Thin Crust doesn’t always meet them.

In a 10-pizza taste test, it landed in the bottom half. The crust turned hard and tough when reheated, and the tester felt it was pricier than most for a pizza that was only okay. In a separate thin crust test, another CPK pizza was faulted for its small size and high price.

Some people like the cheese blend, but the crust and price hold it back.

For a thin crust cheese pizza that tastes better for the money, try Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Crust Four Cheese, which ranked near the top of the same taste test.

19. Home Run Inn Uncured Pepperoni Classic Pizza

A pepperoni pizza on a baking tray with slices beside it.

Home Run Inn is a famous Chicago pizzeria, and its frozen pizzas have a big following. Its pepperoni pizza, though, ranked second to last in a 10-pizza pepperoni taste test.

The sauce divided the tasters. Some said there seemed to be almost no sauce at all, while others found it bitter and overpowering. Everyone agreed there wasn’t enough pepperoni for a pepperoni pizza. In a separate thin crust test, another tester found the center of Home Run Inn’s pepperoni pizza underdone and floppy and said the pepperoni tasted gamey.

Home Run Inn has plenty of fans, but at its price you’d expect a more consistent pie.

For a pepperoni pizza that more tasters agreed on, try California Pizza Kitchen Double Uncured Pepperoni, which finished near the top of the same test.

20. Rao’s Made for Home Brick Oven Crust Uncured Pepperoni Pizza

A pepperoni pizza with patchy cheese and an unevenly browned crust on a baking tray.

Rao’s is famous for its jarred marinara, so you might expect the sauce on its frozen pizza to be the star. Testers say it isn’t.

In a 10-pizza pepperoni taste test, the sauce on this pizza had a bitter, metallic taste, and the crust reminded testers of a saltine cracker. That is a surprising result for a brand built on its sauce.

Price makes it sting more. Rao’s frozen pizzas are among the more expensive options in the freezer case, so a disappointing pie feels like money wasted. Rao’s cheese pizza, on the other hand, has done well in other taste tests, so the pepperoni version seems to be the weak spot.

For a premium pepperoni pizza with fewer complaints, try DiGiorno Premium Pepperoni Wood Fired Style Crust, which placed higher in the same test.

21. Simple Truth Organic Ultra Thin Crust Uncured Pepperoni Pizza

A thin-crust pepperoni pizza on a baking tray.

Simple Truth Organic is Kroger’s organic store brand, and this ultra thin pepperoni pizza appeals to shoppers who want organic ingredients at a lower price. In an 11-pizza thin crust taste test, it came in second to last.

Testers said it had a funky, cardboard-like taste and a bland sauce. They also noticed that the pepperoni was unnaturally dark and that the pizza had too much oil.

Organic ingredients are a nice bonus, but they don’t help much if the pizza itself isn’t enjoyable to eat.

For a better thin crust pepperoni pizza, try Jack’s Original Thin Crust Pepperoni or DiGiorno Thin Crust Pepperoni, both of which ranked much higher in the same test.

22. Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Uncured Pepperoni Pizza

A pepperoni pizza on a plate in front of its box on a kitchen counter.

Newman’s Own has a good reputation, and its frozen pizzas often do well in taste tests. The Thin & Crispy Uncured Pepperoni is the exception.

In an 11-pizza thin crust taste test, testers found it doughy and underdone rather than crispy, which is a problem for a pizza with crispy in its name. They also felt there was too little cheese for the price.

Newman’s Own costs more than many mainstream brands, so a pizza that misses on both crust and cheese is harder to forgive.

For a better pepperoni pizza, try Screamin’ Sicilian Holy Pepperoni, which taste testers praised for its sauce and plentiful pepperoni.

23. Caulipower Margherita Pizza

A margherita pizza with melted cheese and basil on a baking tray.

Caulipower made cauliflower crust pizza mainstream, and its Margherita is a popular choice for people avoiding gluten. In one test of 10 supermarket frozen pizzas, though, it was named the worst of the group.

The tester found the crust very thin and bland, comparing it to a water cracker, and said the toppings lacked flavor too, calling the whole pie bland on bland. Online reviews agree: shoppers say the crust tastes like cardboard, and some add their own cheese and tomatoes because there isn’t enough on top. Others say the sauce needs more seasoning.

If you are gluten-free, you have better choices now than you did a few years ago.

Try Cappello’s almond flour crust pizza, which has earned high praise from food writers.

24. bettergoods Gluten-Free Cauliflower Thin Crust Margherita Pizza

A thin-crust margherita pizza with browned edges sits on a baking tray beside an open box.

Bettergoods is Walmart’s newer premium store brand, and most of its frozen pizzas hold up fine in taste tests. The gluten-free cauliflower Margherita is the one that ranked dead last in a 10-pizza taste test of the line.

The tester said the cauliflower crust was crisp in most spots but soggy in others, and that it didn’t taste like cauliflower at all. The toppings were light, and the pizza came across as a very standard Margherita. It is also smaller than the brand’s regular crust pizzas, so you get less food for your money.

None of the bettergoods pizzas were truly bad, but this one gives you the least for the price.

For a gluten-free pizza with a better crust, try Banza’s chickpea crust pizza, which reviewers praise for its thick, crunchy base.

25. DiGiorno Croissant Crust Pepperoni Pizza

A pepperoni pizza with a thick, golden, flaky crust on a kitchen counter.

DiGiorno launched its Croissant Crust pizzas in 2020, promising a buttery, flaky crust. Many buyers say it doesn’t taste like a croissant at all.

In a ranking of DiGiorno’s crust styles, the Croissant Crust came in last. The reviewer found it hard, dry and flavorless, without the delicate layers you’d expect from a croissant. Shoppers online say much the same, with one calling it a croissant in name only.

It can also be hard to find. Some shoppers say their local stores no longer carry it, so check before you plan a meal around it.

If you like DiGiorno, stick with the Original Rising Crust Pepperoni, which is easy to find in most grocery stores.

26. Tombstone Original Pepperoni Pizza

A pepperoni pizza sits beside a plain pizza box on a kitchen counter.

Tombstone has been a budget freezer favorite for generations, and it is usually one of the cheaper name-brand pizzas in the store. It is not a terrible pizza, but it is often a forgettable one.

In an 11-pizza taste test, testers said it needed more cheese and more spice. If you want bold pepperoni flavor, you’ll probably be reaching for the red pepper flakes.

Tombstone still has loyal fans who like it exactly as it is, especially for the price.

For a little more money, Freschetta Naturally Rising Crust Pepperoni gives you a softer crust and a sauce testers liked.

27. Brew Pub Lotzza Motzza Sausage & Pepperoni Pizza

A sausage and pepperoni pizza on a metal baking sheet.

Lotzza Motzza pizzas are known for piling on cheese, and plenty of shoppers love them. The Sausage & Pepperoni version, though, shows up on roundups of frozen pizzas with poor customer reviews.

The main complaint is the taste. Some reviewers describe an off flavor that is tangy or even metallic, while others simply find it bland. One shopper called it greasy and expensive for its size.

Because opinions on this brand are so split, you may want to try a different Lotzza Motzza flavor before giving up on the line.

If you want a meaty pizza with steadier reviews, try Red Baron Classic Crust Pepperoni, a cheaper pick that taste testers rated well.

28. Trader Joe’s Roasted Garlic & Pesto Pizza with Deep Fried Crust

A pesto and roasted garlic pizza with melted cheese and a thick golden crust on a baking tray.

This Trader Joe’s pizza has a big following, thanks to its unusual crust. According to the box, the dough is deep-fried for a chewy texture. Not every shopper is a fan.

In a ranking of Trader Joe’s frozen pizzas, it came in last. The tester said the crust stayed soft and doughy even after the longest cooking time, and the pesto clumped into small mounds instead of spreading out, which made the pizza greasy. With its bready base and light layer of cheese, it ate more like garlic bread than pizza.

Fans love the garlic and pesto flavor, so this one comes down to taste, but if you want a crisp crust, it may let you down.

For a frozen pizza with a more classic crust, try Amy’s Margherita Pizza.

29. Totino’s Ultimate Pizza Uncured Pepperoni

A small pepperoni pizza sits on a baking tray in a kitchen.

Totino’s Ultimate line is the brand’s upgraded party pizza. Totino’s says it carries more meat and cheese than its regular Pepperoni Party Pizza. Even so, it finished last in an 11-pizza thin crust taste test.

Testers said it tasted processed, with an acidic sauce and cheese that seemed stale. The overall flavor reminded them of a kid’s pizza rather than a grown-up dinner.

It is still cheap and quick, and some shoppers buy it as a snack rather than a meal. But if you are hoping the Ultimate name means a big jump in quality, you may be disappointed.

The best pizza in that same taste test was Screamin’ Sicilian Thin & Crispy Pepperoni, and it is worth the extra money if you want a thin crust pepperoni pizza that tastes like pizza.

30. Screamin’ Sicilian Thin & Crispy Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza

A thin pepperoni and sausage pizza with patchy cheese on a baking tray.

Screamin’ Sicilian is one of the best-reviewed frozen pizza brands, which makes this one stand out. In a ranking of the brand’s pizzas, the Thin & Crispy Pepperoni & Sausage came in last.

The crust was inconsistent, extra crunchy at the edges but limp in the center. The reviewer also disliked the cheese, which turned rubbery instead of gooey and melty. And while the meats themselves were good quality, the reviewer wished there were more pepperoni and sausage.

It is not a bad pizza by most standards, but it doesn’t match the rest of the brand’s lineup.

If you like Screamin’ Sicilian, buy the Thin & Crispy Pepperoni instead. It topped an 11-pizza thin crust taste test and gives you the crisp crust this one is missing.

Would you like to save this?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *