The 30 Worst Thanksgiving Store-Bought Foods According to Shoppers

Store-bought Thanksgiving foods save time, but not every item on the shelf is worth the money. Shoppers share their experiences online and in taste tests, and some products draw the same complaints year after year, including bland flavor, odd texture, and poor value.
This list gathers 30 store-bought Thanksgiving products that shoppers often say to skip, from boxed stuffing and canned cranberry sauce to frozen pies, rolls and gravy. For each one you’ll find what people dislike about it and a better product to buy instead, so you can sort out your cart before Thanksgiving on November 26.
1. Ocean Spray Jellied Cranberry Sauce

Ocean Spray’s canned jellied sauce is the most recognizable cranberry product on the Thanksgiving table, and it is also one that shoppers often rank near the bottom. The complaints are consistent. You pop the can open and the sauce slides out as a firm, ridged cylinder that holds the shape of the can.
Many shoppers say the texture is the main problem. It is smooth, gelatinous, and closer to a set jelly than to anything made from fruit. You get no berry pieces, so the sauce can feel more like a sweet gel than a side dish.
Flavor draws criticism too. Reviewers often describe it as very sweet, with only a mild tart edge, and some mention a slight metallic note from the can.
If you want something with more fruit character, try a whole berry sauce such as Trader Joe’s or Wegmans. Making your own takes about 15 minutes with fresh cranberries, sugar, and water, and you control the sweetness.
2. Stove Top Stuffing Mix for Turkey

Stove Top Stuffing Mix for Turkey is one of the most recognized boxed stuffings in American grocery stores. It is also one of the most debated. Some taste tests rate it as a reliable, fluffy option, while shoppers who expect something close to homemade often come away unimpressed.
The most common complaint is the flavor. You may find the seasoning tastes salty and artificial, with the dried herbs and flavor packet standing out more than any real turkey or vegetable taste. The bread pieces are small and soft, so the texture can turn mushy if you add too much liquid or stir it too much.
Shoppers also point out that the mix tastes like it came from a box. Without added ingredients, it has little of the crisp top or chewy edges that many people want from a Thanksgiving side.
If you want a stronger result, buy a loaf of sturdy bakery bread, cut it into cubes and dry it in the oven, then season it yourself with butter, onions, celery, sage and broth. If you want to stay with a box, Mrs. Cubbison’s Seasoned Dressing is a cube-style mix that some shoppers prefer for its bigger, crunchier pieces.
3. Pepperidge Farm Herb Seasoned Stuffing

Pepperidge Farm Herb Seasoned Stuffing does well in many taste tests, yet it still draws complaints from shoppers. If you read the reviews, you will notice a few themes repeat.
Many shoppers say the cubed bread is dry and sandy when prepared exactly as the box directs. You may end up adding extra broth or butter to avoid a crumbly texture. Others find the herb seasoning too mild, so the dish tastes plain unless you add sausage, onions, celery, or fresh sage.
Some reviewers also point to the sodium level and the dried-out feel of the cubes straight from the bag. A few say the flavor leans on the seasoning packet rather than the bread itself. If you want a bold, homemade taste, the box alone may leave you underwhelmed.
You also pay a little more than you would for a basic boxed mix, which some shoppers feel is hard to justify for a product that needs help.
If you want a better result, cut a loaf of good bakery bread into cubes, dry them in a low oven, and add your own stock, aromatics and fresh herbs for deeper flavor and better texture.
4. Idahoan Original Mashed Potatoes

Idahoan Original Mashed Potatoes are one of the most recognizable instant potato products in the grocery aisle. Shoppers often reach for them because they cook in minutes and require only water or milk. Still, plenty of reviewers say the results fall short of what you want on a holiday table.
The most common complaint is texture. When you stir the flakes, the potatoes can turn gluey or pasty, especially if you mix them too long or use too much liquid. Some shoppers also report a thin, slightly artificial potato taste that does not hold up next to real mashed potatoes.
Saltiness comes up as well. You may find the seasoning stronger than you expect, which leaves less room to adjust the dish with butter, cream, or herbs.
If you want a better option, consider a refrigerated mashed potato product from the grocery deli, which reviewers tend to rate higher for creamy texture. You can also boil Yukon Gold potatoes and mash them with butter and warm milk. It takes about 30 minutes and gives you far more control over flavor.
5. Hungry Jack Mashed Potatoes

Hungry Jack is one of the best-known instant mashed potato brands in grocery stores. It also shows up often on ranked lists of the weaker options. If you pick up a box for Thanksgiving, you should know what other shoppers commonly report.
The most frequent complaint is texture. Many reviewers describe the potatoes as gluey, pasty, or overly smooth, with none of the slight graininess that real mashed potatoes have. You may also notice that the finished dish thickens quickly and turns stiff as it sits on the table.
Flavor is the second issue. Shoppers often say the potatoes taste flat, salty, or artificial, particularly when prepared with water as the box directs. Several taste tests rank the brand below competitors for this reason.
You can improve the result by using milk and butter instead of water. Even so, the base flavor may still fall short of what you expect.
For a better choice, look at refrigerated options like Simply Potatoes mashed potatoes, which taste testers have rated well, or mash your own potatoes with butter and warm milk.
6. Bob Evans Original Mashed Potatoes

Bob Evans Original Mashed Potatoes are one of the most widely available refrigerated sides, and they appear in many Thanksgiving carts for convenience. Shopper opinions are mixed, though, and a fair number of complaints focus on consistency and flavor.
Some buyers report that a container tasted noticeably sweet, which is not what most people expect from a savory side. Others say the texture came out runnier than previous batches, which makes it harder to serve alongside gravy without the plate turning soupy.
Preparation is another point to consider. The potatoes take longer to heat in the microwave than some competing options, which matters when your stovetop and oven are already occupied.
If you want a store-bought option, try Simply Potatoes mashed potatoes or the fresh mashed potatoes many grocery delis make in-house, which shoppers often say taste closer to homemade.
7. Heinz HomeStyle Roasted Turkey Gravy

Heinz HomeStyle Roasted Turkey Gravy is easy to find and comes ready to heat, which makes it appealing when your stovetop is already crowded. Shoppers still report a few consistent problems once it reaches the table.
The most common complaint is the flavor. Reviewers describe it as unexpectedly sweet and slightly acidic, and some say those notes overpower the turkey taste you expect. If you serve it next to stuffing or cranberry sauce, the sweetness can compete with those dishes.
Salt is another frequent comment. Store-bought gravy tends to run salty, and some shoppers say this one is no exception. You may find it needs thinning or balancing with unsalted stock.
Some shoppers also say it tastes more like a jarred product than a homemade gravy, which matters if you want it to pass as made from scratch.
If you want a better option, try the seasonal boxed turkey gravy from Trader Joe’s, which some shoppers prefer for its simpler flavor, though others find it bland and season it themselves. Gravy made from your own pan drippings beats both.
8. Campbell’s Turkey Gravy

Campbell’s canned turkey gravy comes in a small 10.5-ounce can that sits on almost every grocery shelf, which makes it an easy item to toss in your cart. Shoppers who try it often come away underwhelmed, though.
The most common complaint is flavor. You may find the gravy tastes more salty than savory, with little roasted depth. Some shoppers also say the turkey taste is faint and that it reads as generic brown gravy.
Texture is another sticking point. The gravy can come out of the can thick and gelatinous, and you may need to thin it with broth or water to get a pourable consistency.
If you want a better result, consider a packet mix such as Pioneer Roasted Turkey Gravy Mix, which you whisk with water and can cook down as thick as you like. You can also stir a spoonful of your own pan drippings into any store-bought gravy to improve both flavor and body.
9. McCormick Turkey Gravy Mix

McCormick Turkey Gravy Mix is a packet of powder you stir into water and heat on the stove. It is inexpensive and easy to find, which is why it shows up on so many Thanksgiving shopping lists. It also draws mixed reactions from the people who use it.
The most common complaint is flavor. Some shoppers find the gravy tastes salty and artificial, with a seasoning-packet quality that does not resemble real turkey drippings. Others say the texture comes out thin or slightly pasty unless you watch the heat and whisk carefully.
Reviewers in taste tests have been split on it. Some call it a decent quick base, while others rank it well below jarred or homemade gravy. If you cook it as directed, it works in a pinch, but it rarely tastes homemade on its own.
If you want better results, make your gravy from the turkey’s pan drippings, or whisk Better Than Bouillon Roasted Turkey Base into hot water and thicken it with a little butter and flour. Both taste closer to the real thing than powder from a packet.
10. Bruce’s Yams Cut Sweet Potatoes in Syrup

Bruce’s Yams canned sweet potatoes show up on many Thanksgiving tables, usually as the base for a sweet potato casserole. Shopper reviews, though, often point to the same few problems.
The most common complaint is texture. When you open the can, the pieces tend to be soft and mushy, and some fall apart as soon as you drain them. If you plan to bake them in a casserole, that can leave you with a pasty base instead of distinct chunks.
Sweetness is the other issue. The syrup is heavy, and many shoppers say the potatoes taste more like candy than like a vegetable. You may find yourself rinsing them or cutting back on added sugar and marshmallows to make the dish edible.
Some shoppers also report inconsistency, with cans that vary in color, firmness, and flavor from one purchase to the next.
For a better result, buy fresh sweet potatoes and roast or boil them yourself. This takes about an hour, but you control the texture and sweetness. If you want a canned option, look for sweet potatoes packed in water or juice instead of syrup.
11. Marie Callender’s Pumpkin Pie

Marie Callender’s frozen pumpkin pie is a common pick when you want something ready for the oven, but reviews of it are mixed. Several food publications have ranked it below other grocery store options, and some tasters credit competitors with a better overall result.
One frequent complaint concerns the filling. Some shoppers say it bakes up uneven or cracked, which leaves you with a pie that looks messy on the table.
Texture and flavor draw criticism too. Some reviewers describe the filling as mushy, and others say the spice level doesn’t stand out. Frozen pies also depend on careful thawing and baking, so results can vary from one pie to the next.
Not every shopper agrees. A few people consider it one of the closest frozen options to a homemade pie, which explains why opinions split.
If you want a more reliable choice, try the pumpkin pie from Costco’s bakery. It tends to score better in store-bought comparisons and looks closer to homemade when served.
12. Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie

Mrs. Smith’s frozen apple pie is a familiar sight in grocery freezers every November, and it has a loyal following. Still, plenty of shoppers report being let down when it comes out of the oven.
The most common complaint is the crust. You may find the top layer dry, crumbly, or unevenly browned, with some people describing a taste that leans more toward shortening than butter.
The filling draws criticism too. Reviewers often describe it as thick and gelatinous, with apple slices that are soft and a flavor that is mostly sweetness and cinnamon rather than fruit.
Baking results can also vary. A pie that looks fine in the oven may end up with a pale bottom or a filling that sets too firmly once it cools.
If you want a better option, pick up a fresh pie from a local bakery or your grocery store’s bakery counter, and warm it briefly before serving. If you bake from frozen, look for a pie with an all-butter crust, which usually tastes richer.
13. Walmart Freshness Guaranteed Pumpkin Pie

Walmart’s Freshness Guaranteed pumpkin pie, sold in the store’s bakery section, is a common grab for last-minute hosts, but reviews are mixed. You will find shoppers who say the pie is fine for the price, and others who describe it as a letdown.
The most frequent complaint is the filling. Some shoppers report a texture that is mushy or dry rather than smooth and custardy. Others say the pumpkin flavor is faint, with spice and sugar standing out more than the squash itself.
Sweetness comes up often too. Reviewers who tried it in side-by-side tastings described it as too sweet and under-seasoned, which leaves the pie tasting flat despite the sugar. You may also notice that the crust looks pale and can be on the soft side.
Opinions are not unanimous. A few tasters rated it well for a noticeable cinnamon note, and some found the filling more pumpkin-forward than competing pies.
If you want a more reliable option, buy a pie from a local bakery, where many are made fresh for the holiday, or bake your own with canned pure pumpkin and a good crust so you control the sugar and spice.
14. Libby’s Easy Pumpkin Pie Mix

Libby’s Easy Pumpkin Pie Mix is a canned filling that already contains pumpkin, sugar, and spices. You stir in eggs and evaporated milk, pour it into a crust, and bake. The appeal is speed, but shoppers commonly report a few drawbacks.
The most frequent complaint is sweetness. Each 1/3 cup serving lists 18 grams of sugar, and some bakers find the finished pie too sweet and one-note. Because the spices are already mixed in, you also can’t adjust the cinnamon, ginger, or nutmeg to your taste.
Some home bakers also say the pie tastes less rich than one made from scratch. Others point out that the cost and the loss of control aren’t worth the minutes saved, since a from-scratch filling only takes a few extra steps.
A better choice is a can of Libby’s 100% Pumpkin Puree. In taste tests, it has ranked well for both flavor and texture. You control the sugar and spices, and the recipe printed on the label gives you a reliable starting point.
15. Pillsbury Refrigerated Pie Crusts

Pillsbury’s refrigerated pie crusts are one of the most common store-bought options at Thanksgiving, which also makes them one of the most criticized. Taste tests and shopper reviews often describe the crust as bland. You may notice it lacks the buttery flavor of a homemade crust.
Texture is another frequent complaint. Some testers found the baked crust tough or chewy rather than flaky, and you may see it shrink or brown unevenly in the oven. Shoppers also report that the dough can crack when you unroll it, especially if it is too cold.
The results are not all negative. Several chefs recommend it for easy handling and versatility, so your experience may depend on what you expect from it. If you want a richer flavor, though, this crust may disappoint.
A better option is an all-butter crust. You can make one with flour, cold butter, salt and ice water, or look for a frozen or refrigerated crust that lists butter as its main fat. Brushing any store-bought crust with egg wash before baking also helps it brown.
16. Pillsbury Original Crescent Rolls

Pillsbury Original Crescent Rolls are a fixture in many Thanksgiving baskets, mostly because they bake in about 12 minutes and need no shaping beyond unrolling the dough. Convenience is the main reason you reach for them, and it is also where the complaints start.
Shoppers often say the rolls taste more like a salty, faintly sweet dough than like real butter. You may also notice the texture is soft and airy rather than layered, so the flakiness people expect from a crescent roll can fall short. Some reviewers describe a doughy center that stays underbaked even when the outside has browned.
Another common frustration is the pop-open can. The dough can burst the seam before you are ready, and once opened, it is hard to reseal if you only need a few rolls.
If you want a better option, look at Immaculate Baking crescent rolls, which shoppers often name as a stronger choice for Thanksgiving. Another route is a bakery-fresh dinner roll from your grocery store, which usually has a richer flavor and better crumb.
17. Rhodes Bake-N-Serv Dinner Rolls

Rhodes Bake-N-Serv Dinner Rolls come as frozen dough balls, and that is the source of most shopper complaints. You have to thaw them and let them rise before baking, which can take a few hours. If you are juggling a full Thanksgiving menu, that wait takes up counter space and oven timing you may not have.
Results can also vary. Some reviewers say the rolls turn out dense or doughy when the rise is rushed, and others report they bake up pale or bland compared with bakery-style rolls. The dough balls can also stay small and tight if the room is too cool.
On the plus side, the rolls can bake into a decent homemade-style roll when you give them enough time to rise. Still, the effort is hard to justify if you want something reliable.
If you want a better option, try King’s Hawaiian Original Hawaiian Sweet Rolls, which come ready to eat, or pick up fresh rolls from your store’s bakery during Thanksgiving week.
18. Sister Schubert’s Parker House Style Yeast Rolls

Sister Schubert’s Parker House Style Yeast Rolls are sold frozen in a foil pan, already shaped and packed tightly together. They have a loyal following, but not every shopper agrees they deserve a spot on the Thanksgiving table.
The most common complaint is texture. You may find the rolls dense or bready rather than light and pillowy, especially if they stay in the oven too long. Some shoppers also say the rolls taste more like a generic yeast bread than a buttery dinner roll.
Oven time is another sore spot. The package directions call for baking the frozen rolls covered with foil at 300°F for 25 to 35 minutes, which is a long stretch of oven space on a day when the turkey and casseroles need it too. Heat them too long and the bottoms can turn hard and dry.
If you want a more convenient option, pick up fresh rolls from your store’s bakery, which only need a few minutes to warm and often taste closer to homemade.
19. Jennie-O Oven Ready Turkey

The Jennie-O Oven Ready Turkey is a frozen whole bird sealed in a cooking bag. You skip the thawing and put it straight in the oven, which is the main reason it appeals to busy hosts.
Shoppers say the convenience comes with trade-offs in texture and flavor. Common complaints describe dark meat that turns rubbery, even when the bird is cooked longer than the package suggests. Others call the meat stringy, dry, or bland, and some note that the turkey is brined heavily, which can leave it tasting salty or processed.
You also give up some control. The bag limits browning, so the skin often comes out pale rather than crisp, and the pan juices are less useful for gravy.
If you want better results, buy a regular fresh or frozen whole turkey and thaw it in the refrigerator, which takes about one day for every 4 to 5 pounds, according to the USDA. Then roast it in an open pan. You will need to plan ahead, but you get firmer meat, crisper skin, and a better base for gravy.
20. Butterball Boneless Turkey Roast

The Butterball Boneless Turkey Roast is a popular shortcut for small gatherings. It is a netted roast of white and dark meat that comes frozen with a gravy packet and skips the hassle of carving around bones. You still get a holiday centerpiece, but shoppers often say the results fall short of a traditional bird.
The most common complaint is texture. Because the roast is shaped from boneless meat and held together in a net, you may find it springy or processed rather than tender and natural. Many reviewers also say it dries out easily, especially if you cook it past the recommended internal temperature.
Flavor is another sore spot. The ingredient list shows water, salt, sugar and sodium phosphate added to the meat, so some shoppers find it salty without tasting much like roasted turkey. The small roast also gives you far fewer drippings than a whole bird, so you end up leaning on the included gravy packet.
If you want a smaller option with better flavor, buy a fresh bone-in turkey breast from a butcher or the meat counter. It cooks faster than a whole turkey, keeps its moisture better, and leaves you with bones for stock.
21. Reddi-wip Original Whipped Topping

Reddi-wip is the most recognizable canned whipped topping in the store, and it sits on a lot of Thanksgiving pie tables. Shoppers who dislike it tend to point to the same few things.
The most common complaint is sweetness. Some tasters describe the flavor as closer to powdered sugar than to cream, which can compete with an already sweet pumpkin or pecan pie. If corn syrup in the ingredient list bothers you, note that it is there, along with mono and diglycerides, which some shoppers prefer to avoid.
Texture is the other issue. The foam is light and airy, but it deflates within minutes once it hits a warm slice. You may end up with a thin puddle on the plate before dessert is finished.
If you want a better result, whip heavy cream with a little sugar and vanilla just before serving. It takes about five minutes with a hand mixer and holds its shape longer. For a ready-made option, look for a canned topping with a shorter ingredient list and less added sweetener.
22. Cool Whip Original Whipped Topping

Cool Whip is a staple on many Thanksgiving tables, but plenty of shoppers find it hard to defend as a topping for a holiday pie. The most common complaint is that it tastes more like sweetened foam than cream.
The texture draws criticism too. It is light and airy, which helps it hold its shape on pumpkin and apple pie, but some people find it slightly off, with a spongy feel that does not melt the way real whipped cream does.
Ingredients are another sticking point. Cool Whip is a whipped topping rather than whipped cream, and the label lists items like hydrogenated oils, corn syrup, and stabilizers. If you prefer simple, dairy-based ingredients, that list may not appeal to you.
A better choice is real whipped cream. You can whip heavy cream with a little sugar and vanilla in about five minutes. If you want a store-bought option, look for a carton or can that lists cream as the first ingredient.
23. Del Monte French Style Green Beans

Del Monte French Style Green Beans are a common pantry staple, and many shoppers keep a can or two on hand for holiday cooking. The brand is widely available, and the cans carry a solid average rating on retail sites. Still, shoppers who put them on the Thanksgiving table often find them disappointing.
The most frequent complaint is texture. French style beans are cut into thin strips, and after canning they tend to turn soft and limp. When you heat them for a casserole, they can break down further and lose any bite.
Flavor is the other issue. Shoppers often describe the beans as bland, with a muted taste and a briny, metallic note from the canning liquid. You may find yourself adding a lot of seasoning, butter, or bacon just to make them taste like something.
If you want a better result, consider frozen green beans, which hold their shape and taste fresher. Fresh green beans, trimmed and blanched, are better still. If you prefer canned, try a store brand or another brand that reviewers rank higher for firmness.
24. Campbell’s Cream of Mushroom Soup

Campbell’s Cream of Mushroom Soup is a staple of green bean casserole, yet many shoppers find it a letdown. If you read reviews and taste tests, the most common complaint is the texture. Some describe it as overly thick and starchy, with a consistency that feels gluey rather than creamy.
Flavor is another sticking point. You may notice a muted mushroom taste and an aftertaste that some reviewers call odd or lingering. The soup is built to work as a base, so on its own it can come across as bland or heavy.
Sodium is the other frequent concern. Each serving of the condensed soup carries a big share of the daily limit, and the FDA advises adults to keep sodium to less than 2,300 mg a day. That matters if you are already serving salty stuffing, gravy, and ham.
If you want a better result, make a quick homemade cream of mushroom base from butter, flour, milk, and sautéed mushrooms. If you prefer the convenience of a can, look for a lower-sodium cream of mushroom soup or an organic version with a shorter ingredient list.
25. French’s Crispy Fried Onions

French’s Crispy Fried Onions are a staple topping for green bean casserole, and many households buy a can every November out of habit. That familiarity hasn’t kept shoppers from complaining about the product.
The most common criticism is that the flavor has changed. Some shoppers say they remember a noticeable onion taste, but now mostly taste grease and crunch. If you use these onions as the main flavor in your casserole, that gap can be easy to notice.
Another complaint is that the onions can feel oily, which is more apparent when you eat them straight from the container.
If you want a stronger onion taste, consider Fresh Gourmet Crispy Onions, which shoppers often describe as savory, salty, and crisp. Taste tests of other store brands have also placed several competitors ahead of French’s.
For the best result, bake your onions for a few minutes before topping the casserole. This restores some crispness and brings out more flavor.
26. Green Giant Cream Style Sweet Corn

Green Giant Cream Style Sweet Corn is easy to find and shows up on many Thanksgiving tables, especially in casseroles and corn pudding. It is also a product that shoppers frequently criticize in taste tests and rankings.
The most common complaint is texture. You get a thick, pasty base that some reviewers describe as gluey, with kernels that can taste overcooked. The flavor leans sweet, which some shoppers say makes it taste more like a dessert side than a savory one.
Another point that comes up is the ingredient list. It includes sugar and modified corn starch, and some shoppers prefer corn with fewer added ingredients.
If you want a better result, start with plain canned or frozen whole kernel corn and make your own creamed corn with butter, cream, and a little salt. If you prefer to stay with canned, compare store brands and read the ingredient labels before you buy.
27. Stouffer’s Macaroni & Cheese

Stouffer’s Macaroni & Cheese is a frozen staple that often shows up on holiday tables when you need a side dish with little effort. Many shoppers say it falls short of what they expect from a cheesy baked pasta.
The most common complaint is sodium. Like many frozen meals, it is high in salt and saturated fat, which matters when the rest of your Thanksgiving menu is already rich.
Texture and flavor draw criticism too. Reviewers often describe the sauce as thin or greasy, with a mild cheese taste that doesn’t match the photo on the box. Some say the noodles turn soft after heating.
You can do better by making your own baked mac and cheese from a simple recipe. A box of pasta, sharp cheddar, milk, and butter takes little extra time and lets you control the salt. If you want a frozen option, compare nutrition labels on other brands before you buy, since sodium varies widely.
28. Swanson Chicken Broth

Swanson Chicken Broth is one of the most recognizable cartons on the shelf, and it shows up in plenty of Thanksgiving carts for stuffing, gravy, and soup. That familiarity doesn’t mean every shopper is happy with it.
The most common complaint is flavor. You may find the standard version tastes thin and somewhat flat, with a salty edge that doesn’t read as real chicken. Some shoppers also point out that the sodium level in the regular broth can make it hard to control the seasoning in a long-simmered gravy or dressing.
Another frequent criticism is inconsistency. Shoppers report that the taste and richness can differ between cartons and between versions, such as regular, low sodium, and organic.
If you want more control, choose the low-sodium version and season it yourself. A rich homemade stock made from your turkey carcass is a stronger option still, and the leftovers can go straight into a turkey rice soup the next day.
29. Kraft Jet-Puffed Marshmallows

Jet-Puffed marshmallows show up on a lot of Thanksgiving tables, mostly on top of sweet potato casserole. Shoppers who buy them for that job tend to have the same complaints.
The most common one is sweetness. Corn syrup and sugar lead the ingredient list, and you may find the marshmallows push an already sweet side dish into dessert territory.
Texture is another sticking point. Reviewers often describe the marshmallows as bland and rubbery when baked, with little flavor beyond sugar. They can also melt into a sticky, uneven layer, and bags that sit too long on a shelf tend to harden or clump together.
Some shoppers also object to the ingredient list, which includes artificial flavor.
If you want a better option, try Dandies vegan marshmallows, which have a cleaner ingredient list and brown well in the oven. You can also skip marshmallows and use a brown sugar and pecan streusel, which adds crunch instead of extra sugar.
30. Krusteaz Honey Cornbread & Muffin Mix

Krusteaz Honey Cornbread & Muffin Mix is easy to find and takes less than 30 minutes to prepare. You add milk, oil, and an egg, then bake. For a busy Thanksgiving, that convenience is the main draw.
The complaints focus on taste and texture. If you prefer savory cornbread, you may find this mix too sweet, since the honey flavor leans closer to cake than to a traditional Southern-style side. Some reviewers also describe the baked result as crumbly and dry, especially if it bakes a minute or two too long.
The ingredient list is another sticking point. The mix uses degermed yellow cornmeal, which gives a softer, more uniform crumb but less of the gritty corn flavor some cooks want.
If you want a better boxed option, Jiffy is a common pick for a simple, less sweet cornbread. Martha White is another choice if you want a more traditional taste. For stuffing or dressing, a savory mix will hold up better than a sweet one.
