The 30 Worst Red Lobster Dishes According to Diners

Four diners look unimpressed at a table of seafood dishes in a casual seafood restaurant.

Red Lobster has been the place many Americans go for a seafood night out since 1968, and plenty of diners still drive in for the Cheddar Bay Biscuits, the snow crab and a good lobster tail. But a menu this big has weak spots, and some dishes keep drawing the same complaints year after year.

We went through published taste tests, reader polls and diner reviews from Tasting Table, The Takeout, Mashed, Chowhound, The Daily Meal and PureWow to find the Red Lobster dishes people most often regret ordering. The same problems come up again and again: fried seafood that arrives soggy or tastes mostly of breading, small portions for the price, gluey pasta sauces and lobster sides with very little lobster. Every dish below is on the current Red Lobster menu, and the calorie and sodium numbers come from the chain’s own nutrition guide dated November 16, 2026. Quality can vary from one location to the next, so your plate may turn out better or worse. If you’re also planning an Italian night out, see our list of the worst Olive Garden dishes according to diners.

1. Admiral’s Feast

A fried seafood platter with shrimp, flounder, clam strips and bay scallops with cocktail and tartar sauce.

The Admiral’s Feast piles Walt’s Favorite Shrimp, wild-caught flounder, clam strips and bay scallops onto one plate, all fried golden brown, with cocktail sauce, tartar sauce and two sides. It sounds like a sampler of the sea, but it tops more “skip it” lists than any other Red Lobster dish.

Chowhound put it first on its 2025 list of Red Lobster meals to avoid, pointing to reviews that describe the seafood as soggy, rubbery or cold, with quality that swings from one location to the next. Tasting Table’s reviewers said everything on the plate ends up tasting like the same breading, and The Takeout found diners calling it dry and mostly batter.

It’s also one of the heaviest plates on the menu. Red Lobster lists it at 1,670 calories and 4,820 mg of sodium before you add your sides, more than double the 2,300 mg a day the FDA recommends for adults.

Order instead: The Grilled Lobster, Shrimp and Salmon, which gives you the same variety without everything coming out of the fryer.

2. Crispy Dragon Shrimp

Fried shrimp coated in a glossy sweet chili sauce served with rice.

Crispy Dragon Shrimp are fried shrimp tossed in a sweet chili sauce that Red Lobster calls “mildly spicy.” Reviewers haven’t found much spice.

Tasting Table ranked it dead last out of 18 popular Red Lobster dishes, saying the sauce was all sugar and no heat. Chowhound named it one of three appetizers to avoid in 2025, citing reviews that describe mushy breading, a skimpy amount of shrimp and a price that feels steep for what arrives. Some reviewers called it bland, while others said it was too salty.

As a starter, it comes in at 1,010 calories, 22 grams of sugar and 2,010 mg of sodium, which is a lot for something meant to be shared before the main course.

Order instead: The Crab Queso, a cheesy crab dip with pico de gallo and tortilla chips that many diners rate as one of the better starters.

3. Hand-Breaded Calamari

A plate of fried calamari rings with a dipping sauce and lemon wedge.

When Mashed asked 614 people to name the worst appetizer at Red Lobster, about one in four picked the Hand-Breaded Calamari, putting it at the top of the poll.

Reviews explain why. Tasting Table’s roundup found complaints about rubbery squid, soft breading and a small basket for the price, though the jalapeño ranch dipping sauce earned some praise. The Takeout collected reviews calling it bland, tough and greasy, with several diners saying the portion has shrunk. Mashed added that it loses its crunch quickly, so it travels badly as a takeout order.

It isn’t a light start either. Red Lobster lists the calamari at 1,000 calories, 70 grams of fat and 2,070 mg of sodium.

Order instead: The Bacon-Wrapped Sea Scallops, which come four to an order at 450 calories.

4. Garlic Shrimp Scampi

Garlic shrimp scampi baked in butter sauce with a lemon wedge and green beans.

Garlic Shrimp Scampi should be a simple win: shrimp baked in a garlic butter sauce, served with a side. Instead, it landed at the top of Tasting Table’s list of Red Lobster items to think twice about.

The most common complaint is the sauce. Reviewers have compared it to movie-theater butter and said the garlic tastes more like garlic powder than fresh cloves. Chowhound’s review roundup described the shrimp as small, rubbery and greasy, with some longtime customers saying they now get fewer shrimp than they used to. The Takeout found similar reports of tough, bland shrimp.

The portion is small, too. Red Lobster’s nutrition guide lists the scampi at just 220 calories and 12 grams of protein, which tells you how few shrimp are in the dish.

Order instead: The Garlic Lover’s Salmon, which gets a garlic herb butter on a full grilled fillet.

5. Seafood-Stuffed Mushrooms

Seafood-stuffed mushrooms topped with cheese and breadcrumbs.

Red Lobster’s Seafood-Stuffed Mushrooms are filled with its signature seafood topping and baked with Monterey Jack cheese. Chowhound named them one of three Red Lobster appetizers to avoid in 2025.

The reviews it found describe the mushrooms as rubbery, cold, dry and grainy, with a filling that tastes bland. The Takeout collected complaints that they come out greasy and heavy on cheese, and some diners said the filling tasted fishy. Mashed reported that a third of its testers spat theirs out.

Not everyone dislikes them. A PureWow food editor liked the filling and the garlic sauce but wished the breadcrumbs were crisper. Still, at 360 calories and 1,000 mg of sodium for a few mushrooms, they’re an easy appetizer to skip.

Order instead: An extra basket of Cheddar Bay Biscuits, the starter almost everyone agrees on.

6. Popcorn Shrimp

A basket of small fried popcorn shrimp with dipping sauce and lemon.

Popcorn Shrimp is bite-sized shrimp fried golden brown and served with cocktail sauce. Chowhound listed it as one of the three Red Lobster appetizers to avoid in 2025.

The issue is the shrimp itself. Reviewers say the current version uses much smaller shrimp than before, so each bite is mostly batter. Several also said the breading arrives soggy instead of crunchy, which defeats the point of popcorn shrimp.

The starter portion has 820 calories, 51 grams of fat and 1,300 mg of sodium. That’s a lot of fried breading for very little seafood.

Order instead: A cup of New England Clam Chowder, which reviewers in Mashed’s side-dish ranking called reliably good.

7. Mozzarella Cheesesticks

Breaded mozzarella sticks with a cup of marinara sauce.

Mozzarella sticks are hard to get wrong, but Red Lobster’s version came in last place when Mashed ranked chain restaurant mozzarella sticks from worst to best.

Tasting Table’s reviewers said they taste like frozen sticks from the grocery store, with the marinara doing most of the work. The Takeout found reports of sticks that were undercooked on one visit and overcooked with barely any cheese inside on the next. In a Mashed reader poll, about one in five people named them the worst appetizer at the chain.

Mashed also made a simple point: you’re at a seafood restaurant. An order has 730 calories and 2,130 mg of sodium, and you can get the same thing at almost any bar or chain.

Order instead: A cup of the new Chicken Tortilla Soup, at 160 calories.

8. Fish and Chips

Beer-battered fried fish with fries, tartar sauce and lemon.

Red Lobster’s Fish and Chips is beer-battered wild-caught cod served with Chesapeake fries and coleslaw. It’s also the Friday deal, so plenty of diners order it.

The reviews are split, but the complaints are consistent. The Takeout found diners describing greasy fish that was almost all batter, soggy fries and small portions for the price, and one reviewer said the fish tasted frozen. Chowhound’s roundup described small, dry pieces of fish under soggy batter. A Reddit report cited by Tasting Table described undercooked chunks at one location.

Tasting Table’s own taste test liked the batter, which shows how much the dish depends on the kitchen you visit. The full plate has 1,520 calories and 3,480 mg of sodium.

Order instead: The Atlantic Salmon, grilled, at 510 calories before sides.

9. Cajun Chicken Linguini Alfredo

Sliced blackened Cajun chicken over linguine in creamy Alfredo sauce.

The Cajun Chicken Linguini Alfredo tops linguini and creamy garlic Alfredo sauce with spicy chicken. Chowhound wrote a whole article in 2025 about why diners should avoid it.

Reviewers described the chicken as dry and rubbery, almost like it had been reheated, and the sauce as gluey and too thick. The biggest letdown was the seasoning: many diners said the Cajun spice barely comes through, so it eats like plain chicken Alfredo.

It has fans. Mashed called it the best Alfredo option on the menu. But at 1,050 calories, 18 grams of saturated fat and 2,800 mg of sodium, it’s a heavy plate to gamble on.

Order instead: The Parmesan-Crusted Chicken, at 650 calories, if you want chicken at Red Lobster.

10. Creamy Lobster Mashed Potatoes

Mashed potatoes topped with lobster meat in a creamy butter sauce.

This side tops mashed potatoes with Maine and langostino lobster meat in a creamy lobster beurre blanc sauce. It sounds like an upgrade, but diners often say it isn’t worth the extra money.

The Takeout and Chowhound both found reviews describing cold, overcooked lobster in tiny pieces and potatoes that turned gummy or gluey. Some diners pointed out that much of the meat is langostino, a small crustacean that isn’t the same as Maine lobster. Reviewers in Mashed’s side-dish ranking said the sauce carries the dish, and the lobster could be almost anything.

In a Mashed poll of 602 people, about 12% named it the worst side at Red Lobster.

Order instead: The Roasted Asparagus, just 90 calories and a fresh contrast to fried seafood.

11. Chesapeake Fries

A basket of seasoned french fries on a restaurant table.

Red Lobster’s fries come seasoned as Chesapeake Fries and land on plates like the Fish and Chips, the Cheeseburger and the Sailor’s Platter. They’re one of the least-loved sides on the menu.

Tasting Table’s 2025 look at the fries found them soggy, oily and flavorless, and the writer suspected they’re frozen fries given little care. Reddit users said they used to be crispier. In a Mashed poll of 602 people, 23% named the fries the worst Red Lobster side, second only to the Brussels sprouts, and Mashed’s later side ranking put them near the bottom for soaking up grease.

A side order has 510 calories and 1,170 mg of sodium.

Order instead: The Green Beans, a lighter side that won’t go limp on the plate.

12. Baked Potato

A plain baked potato with butter and sour cream on a side plate.

A baked potato seems impossible to mess up, yet it came in last of 15 sides when Mashed ranked Red Lobster’s side dishes in 2024.

Customers in that ranking said the potato often arrives overcooked and sometimes cold. Mashed’s list of things to never order at Red Lobster made another point: you can bake the same potato at home for a fraction of the price. Tasting Table also listed the baked potato among the chain’s disappointing sides.

The sodium is the surprise. Red Lobster lists the plain baked potato at 270 calories but 1,730 mg of sodium, about three-quarters of a full day’s limit, before you add any toppings.

Order instead: A House Side Salad, at 160 calories and 230 mg of sodium.

13. Creamy Lobster Baked Potato

A baked potato topped with lobster meat in a creamy butter sauce.

The Creamy Lobster Baked Potato takes the same baked potato and covers it in Maine and langostino lobster meat in a lobster beurre blanc sauce. Tasting Table ranked it 15th out of 18 popular Red Lobster dishes.

Its reviewers called it a pointless combination and overpriced for the amount of lobster on top. Another Tasting Table piece described a microwaved-tasting potato with a thin, watery sauce and lobster that seemed less fresh than in the chain’s main lobster dishes. Mashed’s side ranking found reviews mixed, placing it 11th of 15.

The topping also pushes the sodium to 2,310 mg, just above the FDA’s daily limit for adults, in a side dish.

Order instead: Add a Maine Lobster Tail to your entrée, which gets you real lobster meat for 420 calories.

14. Lobster and Shrimp Linguini

Linguine with shrimp and lobster in a creamy sauce on a white plate.

The Lobster and Shrimp Linguini combines Maine and langostino lobster meat, shrimp and fresh tomatoes with linguini in a creamy lobster sauce. On paper, it’s one of the most appealing pastas on the menu.

In practice, The Takeout found diners describing it as bland and watery, with too little sauce to hold the dish together. A dietitian writing for Eat This, Not That! also singled out the lobster linguine as one of the least healthy orders at the chain, and the numbers show why.

Red Lobster lists the full portion at 1,240 calories, 74 grams of fat and 34 grams of saturated fat, which is well over the 20 grams a day used for the Daily Value on food labels. It also carries 3,190 mg of sodium.

Order instead: The Shrimp Linguini Alfredo in the lighter portion, at 580 calories.

15. Crab and Shrimp Linguini Alfredo

Linguine Alfredo with crab meat in a thick creamy sauce.

This pasta tosses lump crab meat and shrimp with fresh tomatoes and asparagus in creamy garlic Alfredo sauce on linguini. It’s the heaviest pasta on the menu.

Mashed’s review of Red Lobster’s crab linguini Alfredo called it bland, saying the crab adds little and the Alfredo is so rich that it drowns out everything else. That’s a problem when crab is the reason you’re paying more.

The full portion has 1,450 calories, 173 grams of carbohydrates and 3,590 mg of sodium. If you love creamy seafood pasta, our list of the worst Cheesecake Factory dishes according to diners covers another chain’s heavy pastas too.

Order instead: The Garlic Lover’s Crab, a full pound of snow crab legs tossed in roasted garlic butter.

16. Brownie Overboard

Warm brownie wedges with vanilla ice cream, caramel, fudge and whipped cream.

The Brownie Overboard is warm brownie wedges with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, topped with caramel, fudge and whipped cream. Tasting Table ranked it 17th of 18 popular Red Lobster dishes, and a 2025 Tasting Table piece told readers to skip it.

The complaint is the brownie itself. Reviewers described it as dry, unimpressive and not quite fresh, with sauces so heavy that they cover up everything else. Mashed’s never-order list called it far too sweet for one person.

Some diners on Yelp and Tripadvisor love it, and Mashed once named it the best dessert. But at 1,020 calories and 84 grams of sugar, it’s a lot to risk on a dry brownie.

Order instead: The Chocolate Wave, the chocolate cake Tasting Table pointed to as the better chocolate dessert.

17. Key Lime Pie

A slice of key lime pie with a graham cracker crust and whipped cream.

Key lime pie is a seafood-restaurant classic, and Red Lobster’s version is a key lime custard on a graham cracker crust with whipped cream. Mashed named it the worst dessert at Red Lobster in its 2024 roundup of the best and worst reviewed items.

Mashed pointed to complaints about ingredients and freshness after a 2024 recipe change. The Takeout found reviewers saying the pie tasted like it came from the freezer, with an artificial lime flavor, a film on top and a crust that was too sweet.

A slice has 580 calories and 55 grams of sugar.

Order instead: The Strawberry Cheesecake Bliss, if you want a creamy dessert, ideally split with the table.

18. Sesame-Soy Salmon Bowl

A glazed salmon bowl with orzo, crispy Brussels sprouts, greens and fried onions.

The Sesame-Soy Salmon Bowl tops orzo rice with soy-ginger-glazed Atlantic salmon, crispy Brussels sprouts, spring mix and crispy onions. A bowl sounds like the lighter choice, but this one isn’t.

Tasting Table’s reviewers said it tastes of little beyond soy sauce saltiness and that the salmon is sometimes overcooked. Tasting Table also flagged its sodium in two separate articles about dishes to rethink at Red Lobster.

Red Lobster’s current nutrition guide lists the bowl at 1,140 calories, 27 grams of sugar and 2,320 mg of sodium, slightly more than a full day’s recommended limit in one bowl.

Order instead: The Chicken Caesar Bowl, at 720 calories.

19. Lobster Flatbread

A lobster flatbread topped with melted cheese and tomatoes on a white plate.

The Lobster Flatbread tops a thin crust with Maine and langostino lobster, mozzarella, parmesan, fresh tomatoes and basil. When a PureWow food editor tried every starter on Red Lobster’s happy hour menu, it came in last of five.

The editor found the crust limp, the cheese hardened and the lobster stringy, likely from sitting under a heat lamp before it reached the table. The lobster flavor and seasoning were good, which made the texture problems more frustrating. Chowhound’s reviewers liked it much more, so freshness seems to decide how it turns out.

It has 800 calories and 2,310 mg of sodium, more salt than the FDA’s full daily limit, in an appetizer.

Order instead: The Garlic Lover’s Lobster, two garlic-poached Maine lobster tails, if lobster is what you came for.

20. Lobster Dip

A ramekin of creamy lobster dip served with bread and crackers.

Red Lobster’s Lobster Dip mixes Maine and langostino lobster with spinach and artichoke in a three-cheese blend, served with tortilla chips and pico de gallo. Tasting Table ranked it 12th of 18 popular Red Lobster dishes.

The reviewer’s take was that it’s a standard spinach and artichoke dip with some lobster stirred in, priced well above what it delivers. Mashed’s reviewers liked it more and called it one of the better starters, so this one depends on what you expect.

The dip has 890 calories, 82 grams of carbohydrates and 1,910 mg of sodium.

Order instead: The Lobster Lover’s Duo, which puts the lobster front and center.

21. Ultimate Feast

A large seafood platter with a lobster tail, snow crab legs and shrimp.

The Ultimate Feast brings a Maine lobster tail, snow crab, Walt’s Favorite Shrimp and garlic shrimp scampi together with two sides. It’s Red Lobster’s signature splurge.

The trouble is that you’re paying for four items that each have their own problems. Mashed called it simply too much food for one person and noted that the seafood doesn’t reheat well, so leftovers aren’t much of a bonus. One DoorDash reviewer complained about small, overcooked shrimp and said the platter wasn’t worth what it costs. It also includes the scampi and Walt’s shrimp that diners criticize on their own.

Before sides, it has 1,280 calories, 49 grams of saturated fat and 4,180 mg of sodium.

Order instead: The Grilled Lobster, Shrimp and Salmon, which keeps the lobster and adds a grilled fillet.

22. Sailor’s Seafood Boil

A seafood boil of shrimp, smoked sausage, corn and red potatoes spilling from a boil bag.

The Sailor’s Seafood Boil is two dozen shrimp with smoked sausage, corn and red potatoes, served in a hot shake-and-serve bag with your choice of flavor. Red Lobster says no substitutions.

When the boils went viral in 2025, Fox News rounded up mixed customer reactions. Complaints included cold corn, burnt sausage, a garlic butter that tasted like the scampi sauce and a flavor that needed more seasoning. A PureWow food editor found the Sailor’s Cajun base very peppery and recommended the pricier Mariner’s boil instead.

The boil itself has 1,320 calories and 4,570 mg of sodium before the sauce. Choosing the Cajun butter sauce adds another 1,280 calories.

Order instead: The Mariner’s Seafood Boil, the version PureWow’s editor preferred.

23. Parrot Isle Coconut Shrimp

Coconut-breaded fried shrimp with a creamy dipping sauce.

Parrot Isle Coconut Shrimp is hand-breaded jumbo coconut shrimp with Red Lobster’s piña colada dipping sauce. It has loyal fans, but it also lands on several lists of things to skip.

Mashed’s list of what to never order at Red Lobster said the shrimp aren’t very jumbo, most of each piece is breading, the coconut flavor is faint and the sauce is far too sweet. Tasting Table also found it overly sweet, and a Cheapism tester said the shrimp had a chemical taste.

Chowhound’s reviewers, on the other hand, named it their favorite appetizer, so your experience may vary. The appetizer portion has 660 calories and 20 grams of sugar.

Order instead: The Shrimp Linguini Alfredo, if you want shrimp in something richer.

24. Walt’s Favorite Shrimp

Butterflied fried shrimp with fries and cocktail sauce.

Walt’s Favorite Shrimp is hand-breaded, butterflied shrimp, lightly fried and served with cocktail sauce. It also shows up on several combo plates, including the Ultimate Feast and the Admiral’s Feast.

It’s not terrible, but it rarely impresses. The Daily Meal ranked it ninth of 16 chain fried shrimp, noting that the order is only about five pieces and that some reviewers found the shrimp dry or the batter too salty. Mashed said it was the least interesting of Red Lobster’s shrimp in flavor, and other testers said the shrimp needed more seasoning.

The entrée portion has 1,560 mg of sodium for 260 calories of shrimp, which is a lot of salt for a few pieces.

Order instead: The Grilled Shrimp, served with rice, at 250 calories.

25. Bacon Mac and Cheese

A dish of cavatappi macaroni and cheese topped with bacon.

Bacon Mac and Cheese is cavatappi pasta in a creamy cheese sauce topped with bacon. Mac and cheese should be an easy side, but Mashed ranked it 10th of 15 Red Lobster sides.

Reviewers described the cheese sauce as runny and processed-tasting, closer to Velveeta than a real cheese sauce, and said the bacon tasted fake. Some also found it too salty. Tasting Table’s reviewers called the sauce bland.

The side portion has 610 calories, 20 grams of saturated fat and 1,590 mg of sodium.

Order instead: The Hush Puppies, a Southern side that fits a seafood dinner better.

26. Crispy Brussels Sprouts

A bowl of crispy Brussels sprouts with soy-ginger glaze and fried onions.

Red Lobster’s Crispy Brussels Sprouts are drizzled with soy-ginger sauce and topped with crispy onions. They’re the most divisive side on the menu.

In a Mashed poll of 602 Americans, 31% named them the worst Red Lobster side, the highest share of any side in the survey. Mashed noted that some people simply find Brussels sprouts bitter.

Mashed’s later side ranking liked the glaze, so fans of Brussels sprouts may enjoy them. But they have 380 calories, 20 grams of sugar and 980 mg of sodium, which is more than many people expect from a vegetable.

Order instead: The Roasted Asparagus, at 90 calories.

27. Orzo Rice

A small bowl of plain orzo with parsley next to a fork.

Orzo Rice is one of Red Lobster’s default sides and comes with many entrées and bowls. It’s also one of the most forgettable.

Mashed’s ranking of Red Lobster sides put it 12th of 15, with reviewers calling it bland and saying it’s often undercooked or overcooked. The Daily Meal described it the same way: bland, overly salty and inconsistent from visit to visit.

A side has 310 calories and 880 mg of sodium, which is a lot of salt for a plain starch.

Order instead: The Green Beans, if you want a simple side that actually tastes like something.

28. Crispy Chicken Tenders

Breaded chicken tenders with fries and a cup of honey mustard.

Crispy Chicken Tenders are hand-breaded chicken tenders served with honey mustard and two sides. They’re on the menu for people who don’t want seafood, and diners say it shows.

The Daily Meal’s review roundup described them as bland, and Mashed’s never-order list said they’re acceptable but an afterthought at a restaurant built around seafood.

The kids’ menu version alone has 690 calories, 54 grams of fat and 1,150 mg of sodium, before the sides.

Order instead: The Southwest Chicken Bowl, if you’d rather have chicken that isn’t fried.

29. Cheeseburger

A cheeseburger with lettuce and tomato on a brioche bun with fries.

Red Lobster’s Cheeseburger is a grilled patty with cheddar, lettuce and tomato on a brioche bun, served with Chesapeake fries and the chain’s signature sauce.

The Daily Meal found reviews describing burgers that arrive well done and dry even when ordered medium. Mashed made the broader point that the kitchen is built around seafood, so meat dishes are a gamble. Few people go to Red Lobster for a burger, and the reviews suggest there’s a reason.

With fries, the plate has 1,450 calories and 3,220 mg of sodium.

Order instead: The Grilled Chicken Sandwich, if you want something handheld.

30. Salmon New Orleans

Blackened salmon topped with shrimp in Cajun butter sauce with rice and lemon.

Salmon New Orleans is blackened Atlantic salmon topped with shrimp in a Cajun butter sauce and a tomato-cilantro relish, served with lemon and two sides. It’s also the Thursday deal.

Tasting Table’s reviewer found the blackening tasted mostly of paprika and that the cilantro relish felt out of place on a Cajun dish. Another Tasting Table ranking placed it in the middle of the pack, so it has fans, but the flavors don’t come together for many diners.

It’s also much heavier than plain salmon. Red Lobster lists it at 1,170 calories and 77 grams of fat before sides, compared with 510 calories for the grilled salmon.

Order instead: The Atlantic Salmon, simply grilled, which lets the fish speak for itself.

Red Lobster still does plenty of things well, from its Cheddar Bay Biscuits to its snow crab and lobster tails, but these 30 dishes are the ones taste testers and diners most often say to skip. Menus, recipes and prices change, and quality can vary by location, so check the latest menu at your local Red Lobster before you order.

Would you like to save this?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *