The 30 Worst Cracker Barrel Dishes According to Diners

Cracker Barrel has been serving Southern comfort food next to its rocking chairs and country stores since 1969, and plenty of diners swear by its pancakes, hashbrown casserole and mac n’ cheese. But with a menu this big, not every plate lives up to the rest.
We went through published taste tests, reader polls and diner reviews from Tasting Table, The Takeout, Mashed, Chowhound and The Daily Meal to find the Cracker Barrel dishes people most often regret ordering. The same complaints come up again and again: bland or overcooked sides, gluey gravies, dry baked goods and fried food that arrives greasy or overdone. Quality can also vary from one location to the next, so your plate may turn out better or worse. If you’ve worked your way through another big chain, see our list of the worst Olive Garden dishes according to diners too.
1. Lemon Pepper Grilled Rainbow Trout

When Mashed asked 593 people to name the worst dinner item at Cracker Barrel, the lemon pepper grilled rainbow trout won by a wide margin, with about 37% of the vote. An earlier Mashed poll of 645 people also put it at the bottom of the menu.
Tasting Table pointed to diners online who found the fish so heavily seasoned that they called it close to inedible. It also argued that a light grilled fillet is underwhelming next to the hearty comfort food Cracker Barrel does best.
Order instead: If you want something lighter that still feels like Cracker Barrel, Tasting Table’s favorite entrée was the Smokehouse Grilled Chicken.
2. Meatloaf

Cracker Barrel’s meatloaf is a classic Southern plate, but it is also one of its most criticized dishes. In a Mashed poll, more than a fifth of respondents picked it as the restaurant’s worst dinner item, second only to the trout.
When The Takeout ranked meatloaf from 10 chain restaurants based on reviews, Cracker Barrel’s came in last. Diners described gristly, fatty meat and a sweet ketchup glaze that overpowers an otherwise bland loaf. Tasting Table also collected complaints that the meatloaf can be dry and that it tastes microwaved.
Order instead: The Herb Roasted Chicken, which finished in the top three of Tasting Table’s ranking of popular Cracker Barrel entrées.
3. Hashbrown Casserole Shepherd’s Pie

This dish arrived with what Nation’s Restaurant News called Cracker Barrel’s largest menu test in its history, back in 2024. Pot roast and vegetables go under mashed potatoes and a griddled hashbrown casserole crust. It sounds like a great idea, but Tasting Table ranked it dead last of eight popular entrées.
The reviewer called the mashed potatoes gummy and flavorless, the beef and vegetables skimpy and the hashbrown topping greasy. Diners quoted by The Takeout said the dish was dry and the meat was full of fat and sinew, and Chowhound found reviews of plates with a thin hashbrown crust instead of a thick layer.
Order instead: Get the Hashbrown Casserole on its own as a side. The Takeout ranked it the second-best side on the whole menu.
4. Chicken n’ Dumplins

Cracker Barrel’s “dumplins” are flat strips of dough simmered in a thick chicken gravy, and they are one of its most divisive dishes. The Takeout ranked them dead last among 26 sides, describing a gummy, pasty texture, and Mashed put them second to last among 21 sides after finding no chicken and a gluey, flour-heavy sauce in its serving.
Tasting Table also flagged the glue-like sauce and a lack of chicken flavor. Diner reviews collected by The Takeout mention dough that was cold inside and too little chicken, and Chowhound’s roundup of reviews said the dish simply lacks flavor.
Order instead: Mac n’ Cheese, which The Takeout ranked the best side on the menu. If it’s chicken comfort food you’re after, try making our copycat Cracker Barrel chicken noodle soup at home.
5. Carrots

Cracker Barrel’s carrots came in last place in Mashed’s ranking of 21 sides. The reviewer found them overcooked, grainy and soggy, and oddly sweet while still needing salt.
Tasting Table called them one of the worst sides on the entire menu and blamed the use of baby carrots, which turn soggy and bland when they are cooked this long. One diner quoted by The Takeout compared the texture to baby food.
Order instead: Pinto Beans, which Mashed ranked the best of all 21 sides.
6. Biscuits n’ Gravy

Cracker Barrel is famous for its biscuits, which makes this one sting. Tasting Table ranked Biscuits n’ Gravy dead last of nine breakfast dishes. The biscuits were dry and flavorless, and the gravy was thin, watery, salty and so smoky that it tasted more like barbecue sauce than sausage gravy.
Diner reviews gathered by Mashed describe stale, small biscuits and gravy that is far too salty, and one reviewer quoted by The Takeout said the gravy arrived stone cold.
Order instead: The Loaded Hashbrown Casserole, which Tasting Table ranked among its three favorite Cracker Barrel breakfast items.
7. Grits

Grits are a Southern breakfast staple, but Cracker Barrel’s version lost a Mashed reader poll in a landslide. Nearly 33% of respondents named them the worst breakfast item on the menu, more than double the next pick.
When Mashed looked through diner reviews, the same complaints came up again and again: very little flavor and a texture people didn’t enjoy. One diner simply called them horrible.
Order instead: A side of Fried Apples, a sweet favorite that lands in the top 10 of The Takeout’s side dish ranking.
8. Biscuit Beignets

These are made from Cracker Barrel’s buttermilk biscuit dough, deep-fried, tossed in cinnamon sugar and served with butter pecan sauce for dipping. In a Mashed poll of Cracker Barrel desserts, more than 36% of respondents named them the worst one.
Chowhound collected reviews calling them dry inside and saying the frying oil left an off taste. In its own taste test, Chowhound found them more bready than a real beignet, with a butter pecan sauce too thin to cling. Mashed also noted they are drier and denser than New Orleans-style beignets.
Order instead: The Cinnamon Roll Skillet, which Chowhound named its favorite shareable for being warm, gooey and well balanced.
9. Country Fried Pickles

Fried pickles are a regular on Cracker Barrel’s shareables menu, and the chain’s own menu announcements pair them with buttermilk ranch and its Country Comeback Sauce. Even so, Chowhound ranked them last among six Cracker Barrel appetizers.
The batter was too firm and slid right off the pickle, the coating needed more seasoning and the pickle inside was limp, with little dill or brine flavor. They are also a heavy starter: The Daily Meal reported that an order carries about 1,070 calories and 3,860 milligrams of sodium.
Order instead: The Fried Onion Petals, which Chowhound praised as lightly battered and sweet, especially with the Comeback Sauce.
10. White Cheddar Bites

Fried cheese should be an easy win, but Mashed ranked Cracker Barrel’s White Cheddar Cheese Bites last among its appetizers. The reviewers found the cheese a bit bland without the ranch and noted that once the bites cool on the table, they turn chewy.
Chowhound’s taste test put them second to last of six shareables, also calling the outside bland and the cheese less gooey than expected.
Order instead: Hashbrown Casserole Tots, which The Takeout ranked third among 26 Cracker Barrel sides.
11. Classics Sampler

A sampler sounds like the best way to try Cracker Barrel’s greatest hits, but Tasting Table ranked it second to last of eight popular entrées.
Its plate had meatloaf with a pink center, chicken with a tough tendon, a bland dumpling sauce and green beans that were both mushy and too salty. The Daily Meal also pointed out that the Classics Sampler comes to about 1,390 calories before you add sides.
Order instead: Pick one entrée you really like and add two of the best-reviewed sides, such as Mac n’ Cheese and Hashbrown Casserole.
12. Louisiana Shrimp Skillet

Tasting Table ranked this skillet third from the bottom of eight popular Cracker Barrel entrées. The sauce was oily and soupy, the shrimp were rubbery and tasted fishy, the broccoli was mushy with blackened stems and the rice portion was skimpy.
Shrimp has been a weak spot elsewhere on the menu too. Chowhound found diner reviews of the Shrimp n’ Grits Skillet that described rubbery or tough shrimp and too little seasoning.
Order instead: The Saucy Chicken Sandwich, which came in second place in Tasting Table’s entrée ranking.
13. Country Fried Steak

Country fried steak is one of Cracker Barrel’s signature plates, but it collects plenty of complaints. Tasting Table ranked it fourth from the bottom of eight entrées, calling the gravy gelatinous and bland, with mushy carrots and gummy mashed potatoes on the side.
Diners quoted by The Takeout described steak that was tough, overcooked or left too long under a heat lamp, and Chowhound found reviews saying the meat itself tastes bland under all that breading and gravy.
Order instead: The Grilled Chicken Tenders, which Tasting Table notes are a favorite among Cracker Barrel regulars online.
14. Fried Catfish

Tasting Table has panned Cracker Barrel’s fried catfish twice. In its ranking of eight popular entrées, it landed in the bottom five, with greasy, dense hush puppies (only two instead of three) and overcooked turnip greens with bland ham.
In its review of the 2026 spring menu, Tasting Table again called the fish bland, with a thin cornmeal breading that lacked both seasoning and crunch.
Order instead: The Smokehouse Grilled Chicken, Tasting Table’s top pick among Cracker Barrel’s popular entrées.
15. Friday Fish Fry

The Friday Fish Fry is a Friday plate of four battered cod fillets with tartar sauce, a lemon wedge and two country sides, according to Cracker Barrel’s own blog.
Diners aren’t always convinced. Tasting Table put it on its list of Cracker Barrel dishes to avoid, noting that some customers call it “mystery fish” and one found it soft, mushy and strongly fishy.
Order instead: Tasting Table’s honest advice for seafood lovers is to save it for a seafood chain. At Cracker Barrel, stick with the comfort food it does best, like the Hashbrown Casserole and Mac n’ Cheese.
16. Southern Fried Chicken

Diners quoted by The Takeout said Cracker Barrel’s fried chicken was too heavily breaded and cooked far too long.
It’s also one of the heaviest plates on the menu. The Daily Meal reported the Southern Fried Chicken dinner at about 1,640 calories, 100 grams of fat and 4,730 milligrams of sodium. That is about double the 2,300 milligrams a day that the American Heart Association sets as the upper limit for most adults.
Order instead: The Smokehouse Grilled Chicken, which gives you the chicken dinner without the heavy breading.
17. Pot Roast

Cracker Barrel’s slow-braised pot roast has its fans, but it also shows up in The Takeout’s roundup of menu items that keep disappointing customers. Diners there described thin, fatty slices, with one saying it had more fat than meat, and gravy that arrived cold.
When Cracker Barrel dropped its roast beef dishes in early 2025, Chowhound noted that some fans felt the pot roast just isn’t the same.
Order instead: Turkey n’ Dressing, another dish regulars recommend online. It is a seasonal favorite, so ask whether your location has it.
18. Momma’s French Toast Breakfast

Momma’s French Toast is a long-time Cracker Barrel breakfast, but several roundups say it isn’t what it used to be. Mashed collected reviews calling it generic, with thinner bread, less egg flavor and heavy cinnamon, and noted that takeout orders fare even worse.
Chowhound found diners who said the bread had changed and the cinnamon, vanilla and brown sugar flavor was often missing. Reviews quoted by The Takeout described tough bread with weak flavor, and one plate that arrived cold.
Order instead: The Buttermilk Pancakes, which Tasting Table ranked the best of nine Cracker Barrel breakfast items.
19. Old Timer’s Breakfast

The Old Timer’s Breakfast is a classic eggs-and-meat plate, but Tasting Table ranked it third from the bottom of nine breakfast items. The sausage was overwhelmingly smoky, and the eggs ordered over easy came out closer to over medium.
Diner reviews collected by The Takeout point to the same kinds of misses on Cracker Barrel’s bacon and egg plates: overcooked eggs, limp bacon and, at times, eggs that arrived cold.
Order instead: The Country Boy Breakfast, which Tasting Table ranked the second-best breakfast on the menu.
20. Country Ham

Country ham is cured with a lot of salt, and many diners find Cracker Barrel’s version too much. Mashed collected reviews saying it was so salty that it drowned out every other flavor on the plate.
The Daily Meal reported that the country ham on the Country Boy Breakfast adds 3,360 milligrams of sodium, which is more than a full day’s limit on its own.
Order instead: Choose the Buttermilk Pancakes, or ask for a breakfast meat other than country ham with your plate.
21. Cornbread Muffins

The Takeout ranked Cracker Barrel’s cornbread 22nd of 26 sides, finding it dry, excessively salty and missing any sweetness. In another roundup, The Takeout found diners saying the muffins had shrunk, came out dry and hard, and tasted like cardboard, while others thought the recipe had become too sweet.
Chowhound’s review roundup said the same thing in fewer words: dry, crumbly and short on flavor.
Order instead: Ask for the Buttermilk Biscuits instead. The Takeout ranked them far ahead of the cornbread, ninth out of 26 sides.
22. Green Beans

The Takeout ranked Cracker Barrel’s green beans 24th of 26 sides, saying they were steamed to mush with almost no seasoning beyond salt. Reviews collected in a separate Takeout roundup also described them as mushy and overdone, with one diner saying they seemed to come from a can.
Tasting Table had the same issue when green beans came with its sampler plate: mushy and too salty.
Order instead: Turnip Greens, which The Takeout ranked sixth among 26 sides.
23. Seasoned Buttery Rice

Rice should be the easiest side on the menu, but The Takeout ranked Cracker Barrel’s Seasoned Buttery Rice 25th of 26, just ahead of the dumplins.
The reviewer found it oily rather than buttery, undercooked and hard in spots, and short on flavor.
Order instead: Bacon Mac n’ Cheese, which The Takeout ranked fourth among Cracker Barrel’s sides.
24. Lima Beans

Cracker Barrel’s lima beans are supposed to carry some bacon flavor, but The Takeout’s reviewer couldn’t taste any. The beans themselves were mushy and bland, landing 23rd of 26 sides in the ranking.
If you grew up on slow-cooked Southern beans, this side is likely to fall flat.
Order instead: The House Salad, which The Takeout ranked fifth among 26 sides, for something fresher next to a heavy entrée.
25. Corn

Cracker Barrel’s corn shows up near the bottom of almost every side dish ranking. Mashed ranked it fourth from last of 21 sides, finding little sweetness or flavor and almost no seasoning, and The Takeout put it 21st of 26.
Tasting Table included it on its list of dishes to avoid, saying it tastes like plain corn from a can. Reviewers at The Takeout said much the same: canned corn, simply reheated.
Order instead: Steak Fries, which Mashed ranked as the second-best side.
26. Broccoli

Mashed found Cracker Barrel’s broccoli cooked well but completely unseasoned, and ranked it fifth from the bottom of 21 sides. Chowhound’s review roundup used nearly the same words.
The Takeout had a worse plate, describing broccoli that was overcooked and mushy, with a strong overcooked smell, and ranked it 18th of 26.
Order instead: The Loaded Sweet Potato, which ranked fourth among the 21 sides Mashed tried.
27. Loaded Baked Potato

A loaded baked potato should be a sure thing, but Tasting Table put Cracker Barrel’s on its list of dishes to avoid because the toppings seem thrown on rather than generously piled up.
Mashed found its potato firm instead of fluffy, with bacon that wasn’t crispy and slightly rubbery cheese. The Takeout’s reviewer also felt there weren’t enough cheese and bacon to call it fully loaded.
Order instead: The Hashbrown Casserole, which gives you cheesy potatoes done right.
28. Peach Cobbler

Mashed called the peach cobbler the popular Cracker Barrel dessert it would never order again. The reviewer blamed canned peaches in an overly syrupy, artificial-tasting filling, topped with a single piece of crust sticking out of the bowl instead of a proper crumbly topping.
It’s also a rich finish: Mashed noted the cobbler comes to about 530 calories.
Order instead: A slice of Pecan Pie, which topped Chowhound’s ranking of Cracker Barrel’s holiday pies.
29. Double Chocolate Fudge Coca-Cola Cake

Mashed ranked Cracker Barrel’s Double Chocolate Fudge Coca-Cola Cake dead last of 14 casual chain chocolate cakes based on customer reviews. Diners called it dry, with one saying it was dry as a bone, and others said it tasted like it came from a boxed mix.
Mashed also flagged the sugar, about 84 grams per serving, and even in a review where the fudgy frosting won praise, the cake underneath was still dry.
Order instead: The Cinnamon Roll Skillet, a warm, gooey sweet that Chowhound ranked as its favorite shareable.
30. Cinnamon Roll Pie

Cracker Barrel’s holiday pies are back for the season, and Chowhound ranked all five of them in 2026. The Cinnamon Roll Pie came in last.
The reviewer felt Cracker Barrel phoned this one in. The rolls were packed tightly and dry, short on cinnamon and brown sugar syrup, and the cream cheese frosting had a grainy texture.
Order instead: The classic Pecan Pie, which Chowhound ranked first of the five holiday pies.
Cracker Barrel still does plenty of things well, from its pancakes to its hashbrown casserole, but these 30 dishes are the ones taste testers and diners most often say to skip. Menus and recipes change, and quality can vary by location, so check the latest menu at your local Cracker Barrel before you go, and lean on the sides and breakfast plates that reviewers keep praising.
