The 30 Worst Canned Soups According to Shoppers

Canned soup is a pantry staple for good reason. It is quick, affordable and easy to store, but quality varies a lot from one brand and flavor to the next. Some cans deliver a hearty, well-seasoned bowl, while others disappoint with thin broth, mushy vegetables or flavors that lean on salt more than real ingredients.
This list collects 30 canned soups that shoppers often say to skip, from ready-to-eat Chunky and Progresso cans to the condensed soups people keep for casseroles. Salt comes up again and again: many of these cans hold two servings, and the FDA advises adults to keep sodium to less than 2,300 mg a day, so one can can use up a big share of that. Recipes change over time, and one item here is no longer sold, which is marked. If you stock up on pantry food at discount stores, see our list of the worst Dollar General foods according to shoppers too.
1. Campbell’s Chunky Creamy Chicken & Dumplings

Campbell’s Chunky Creamy Chicken & Dumplings puts chicken and dumplings in a thick, creamy base. It sounds like a comforting shortcut, but many shoppers find it falls short of the homemade dish it imitates.
The most common complaint is the dumplings. Reviewers often describe them as soft and doughy, closer to pasta than to a fluffy dumpling. Some also call the sauce bland, so the bowl tastes flat unless you add seasoning.
Shoppers also say the chicken pieces are small and sparse for a soup sold under the Chunky name, and the can carries a lot of sodium for two servings.
If you want something different, Progresso Rich & Hearty Chicken & Homestyle Noodles gives you a lighter broth with chicken, carrots and egg noodles, without the gummy dumplings.
2. Campbell’s Chunky New England Clam Chowder

Campbell’s Chunky New England Clam Chowder is one of the easiest canned chowders to find. Shoppers who review it tend to point to the same two problems: the clams and the base.
You may notice that the clam pieces are small and few. Reviewers often say they expect more clams from a soup with that name, and some find them chewy. Potatoes tend to fill most of each spoonful instead.
The base draws mixed reactions. Some shoppers call it thin, while others find it pasty or salty. Either way, it can taste more like a generic cream soup than a seafood chowder.
For a better can, try Bar Harbor New England Clam Chowder. Reviewers credit it with a briny, clam-forward flavor and a short ingredient list, though it is less chunky.
3. Campbell’s Chunky Baked Potato with Cheddar & Bacon Bits

This soup promises a loaded baked potato in a can, with potato chunks, cheddar and bacon bits. Shopper reactions are mixed, and the complaints follow a pattern.
If you expect a thick, creamy bowl, you may be let down. Reviewers often say the cheese and bacon flavors are faint and the potatoes do most of the work, so the soup tastes flatter than a real loaded potato.
Many buyers treat it as a base rather than a finished meal. They stir in extra cheese, fresh bacon or sour cream to make it taste the way the label suggests.
If you want a creamier potato soup, try Panera Bread Baked Potato Soup from the refrigerated aisle, or make Bear Creek Creamy Potato soup mix, which cooks up thick and lets you add your own toppings.
4. Great Value Condensed Chicken Noodle Soup

Walmart’s Great Value Condensed Chicken Noodle Soup is one of the cheapest cans on the shelf, and the low price is the main reason it ends up in so many carts. Once you open it, though, shopper complaints are consistent.
The most common criticism is the lack of chicken. Reviewers describe finding very little meat, with broth and noodles making up most of the can. Vegetables are sparse too.
Sodium is the other concern. Like other condensed chicken noodle soups, it is high in salt per serving, and the can holds more than one serving, so eating the whole thing adds up quickly.
If you want more chicken in the bowl, Progresso Traditional Chicken Noodle comes ready to heat and generally has more visible meat and vegetables. For more store-brand misses, see our list of the worst Walmart Great Value products.
5. Campbell’s Chunky Sirloin Burger with Country Vegetables

Campbell’s Chunky Sirloin Burger with Country Vegetables is a familiar can in many pantries. It still draws complaints, and they are fairly consistent.
The most common one is the meat. The can promises sirloin burger, but shoppers often report only a few small pieces among the potatoes, carrots and other vegetables. If you buy a Chunky soup expecting a hearty serving of beef, that gap feels like a letdown.
Some shoppers also find the broth plain, with a flavor that reads more like canned vegetables than seasoned beef. Like most Chunky soups, it is high in sodium for a two-serving can.
If you want more beef in every bite, a canned stew such as Dinty Moore Beef Stew has a thicker gravy and larger meat pieces.
6. Campbell’s Chunky Old Fashioned Potato Ham Chowder

Campbell’s Chunky Old Fashioned Potato Ham Chowder sounds like a cozy, smoky bowl. Shoppers who skip it usually point to the texture and the ham.
Many reviewers describe the base as thin for a chowder, without the creamy body they expect. The ham pieces are often called small and few, so the smoky flavor promised by the name does not come through strongly. Some also find the potatoes soft and the seasoning salty.
Sodium is worth checking. Campbell’s lists about 790 mg per one-cup serving, and the 18.8-ounce can holds about two servings.
If you want a richer potato soup, look in the refrigerated aisle for a deli-style potato soup, or use a potato soup mix and add your own diced ham.
7. Campbell’s Chunky Chicken Broccoli Cheese with Potato

Campbell’s Chunky Chicken Broccoli Cheese with Potato is sold as a hearty, fill-you-up can. Campbell’s own label lists 14 grams of protein and 1,940 mg of sodium per can, or 890 mg per one-cup serving. Shoppers still raise a few recurring complaints.
The most common one is the base. You may find it thin and watery for a soup that promises a cheesy, creamy bowl. Many reviewers say the cheese flavor is faint and the broccoli is hard to find.
Texture is another sticking point. The potatoes can turn soft, and the chicken pieces are small. If you expect chunks you can bite into, the can may fall short.
If you want a better broccoli cheese soup, try Panera Bread Broccoli Cheddar Soup from the refrigerated aisle, which shoppers praise for its thick, cheesy base.
8. Campbell’s Chunky Chicken Corn Chowder

Corn chowder sounds like an easy win, which is part of why this can disappoints. Retailer labels list about 850 mg of sodium per one-cup serving, and the 18.8-ounce can holds about two servings.
Shoppers often name the salt as the biggest drawback. If you watch your intake, a full can takes up most of a day’s allowance.
Texture is the other common complaint. The base can taste thick and floury, and the chicken and corn pieces get lost in it. You may find the flavor leans salty and creamy, without much corn sweetness or real chicken taste.
If you like the idea but want less salt, Campbell’s sells a Healthy Request version of this chowder with much less sodium, or you can stir extra corn and cooked chicken into a simpler broth-based soup.
9. Progresso Rich & Hearty Chicken Corn Chowder

Progresso’s chicken corn chowder is made with chicken, corn, potatoes and celery in a bacon-flavored, creamy base. It sounds comforting, but shopper feedback points to a few recurring issues.
One common complaint is the salt. Retailer labels list about 830 mg of sodium per one-cup serving, and the can holds about two servings, so eating the whole can adds up fast.
Texture and flavor draw criticism too. Some shoppers find the base thin for something labeled rich and hearty, and they say the chicken pieces are small. Others feel the bacon flavor tastes artificial rather than smoky.
If you want a thicker chowder, a refrigerated deli corn chowder is a better bet. If sodium is your main concern, look at Progresso’s Reduced Sodium line instead.
10. Progresso Rich & Hearty New England Clam Chowder

Progresso’s clam chowder is one of the most widely stocked canned chowders, but shoppers are divided on it. You may find it doesn’t match the thick, chunky bowl the label suggests.
The most common complaint is the clam content. Reviewers often say the clams are sparse and chewy, and some report finding only a few small pieces among the potatoes.
Texture is another sticking point. Some shoppers describe the base as thin or starchy, with a flavor that leans more toward cream and salt than clam. Retailer labels list about 760 mg of sodium per one-cup serving, and the can holds about two.
If you want more clam flavor, try Bar Harbor New England Clam Chowder. Shoppers generally describe it as tasting more like the sea, with a simpler ingredient list.
11. Healthy Choice Chicken with Rice Soup

Healthy Choice Chicken with Rice is marketed as a lighter canned option, with white-meat chicken, white rice and vegetables in broth. Shoppers who try it often describe the flavor as mild to the point of bland.
Another common complaint is texture. Some reviewers say the broth tastes thin and the rice turns soft and mushy after heating. The chicken pieces are small, so it may not feel like a full meal.
Portion size comes up too. Retailer labels list about 10 grams of protein per can, which some shoppers find too low for lunch, so they end up adding crackers or a sandwich.
If you want more flavor, try Progresso Traditional Chicken Rice with Vegetables, which adds carrots, celery and tomatoes to a heartier broth.
12. Progresso Rich & Hearty Loaded Potato with Bacon

This soup comes in an 18.5-ounce can that holds about two servings. It promises potatoes, bacon and cheese in a creamy base, but many shoppers say the bowl does not match that description.
The most common complaint is the lack of potato. You may open the can expecting chunks and find a mostly smooth, thick base with only a few pieces. Some reviewers say the bacon flavor takes over while the potato takes a back seat.
Texture draws mixed reactions as well. Some find the soup heavy or pasty rather than creamy, and like most creamy canned soups it is high in sodium.
If you want more potato in every spoonful, Campbell’s Chunky Baked Potato with Steak & Cheese is built on roasted russet potato chunks, or pick up a refrigerated potato soup from the deli case.
13. Progresso Rich & Hearty Creamy Roasted Chicken Wild Rice

Progresso’s Creamy Roasted Chicken Wild Rice is a gluten-free, ready-to-heat can that you can have on the table in a few minutes. It sounds appealing, but shopper feedback is mixed.
A common complaint is texture. You may find the base thick and heavy, with a starchy feel that some reviewers compare to gravy. The chicken pieces are often described as small and soft.
Salt is another sticking point. Retailer labels list about 800 mg of sodium per one-cup serving, and some shoppers find the flavor salty but flat.
If you want a lighter chicken and wild rice soup, try Pacific Foods Organic Chicken & Wild Rice, which uses brown and wild rice in a broth-based soup and also comes in a lightly salted version.
14. Progresso Rich & Hearty Broccoli Cheese with Bacon

If you pick up this can expecting plenty of vegetables, you may be disappointed. Shoppers commonly report that the broccoli is sparse and soft, and that the soup reads more like a cheese sauce than a broccoli soup.
Texture is a frequent complaint. You get a smooth, thick base with little to chew on, and some reviewers say the cheese flavor is mild rather than sharp.
Nutrition is another sticking point. Retailer labels list about 800 mg of sodium and 4.5 grams of saturated fat per one-cup serving, and the can holds about two servings.
For a better option, make a quick version at home with fresh broccoli, sharp cheddar and low-sodium broth, so you control both the cheese and the salt.
15. Progresso Rich & Hearty Beef Pot Roast with Country Vegetables

Progresso Rich & Hearty Beef Pot Roast with Country Vegetables is marketed as a soup that eats more like a stew. It comes in an 18.5-ounce can and heats without added water, which is a big reason it sells well.
Shoppers who rate it lower point to the meat. Many reviewers say the beef pieces are small, stringy or hard to find, which makes the can feel more like vegetable soup than pot roast.
Some shoppers also find the broth thin or one-note, and say the potatoes and carrots turn soft after heating. Retailer labels list about 660 mg of sodium per one-cup serving.
If you want a thicker, meatier bowl, a canned beef stew is a better match for what this label promises.
16. Progresso Vegetable Classics Tomato Basil

Progresso’s Vegetable Classics Tomato Basil is a ready-to-eat tomato soup, and shoppers who rank it low tend to point to the same few issues. The flavor is the most common complaint, with some describing it as closer to sweetened tomato sauce than a soup with real depth.
Basil is the selling point, yet you may notice only small flecks of it. If you want a clear herb flavor, the soup can come across as muted.
Sodium is another sticking point. Progresso’s Reduced Sodium Creamy Tomato with Basil was made with about 25% less sodium than this can, which tells you the original is on the salty side.
If you want a better tomato soup, Pacific Foods Organic Creamy Tomato and Amy’s Organic Cream of Tomato are both popular picks for a cleaner tomato flavor, though they cost more per container.
17. Progresso Light Chicken Pot Pie Style Soup

Progresso Light Chicken Pot Pie Style Soup is built around a low calorie count. Progresso lists 90 calories per one-cup serving and 190 for the whole can, which is appealing if you want pot pie flavor without the heft.
The trade-off shows up in the bowl. Shoppers often describe the broth as thin and the flavor as mild compared with the creamy, buttery filling you expect from a pot pie. If you want a rich, filling meal, the light formula may leave you hungry.
Sodium is still high for a light soup. Progresso lists 620 mg per serving, 27% of the daily value, and the can holds two servings.
The word “style” matters too. There is no crust and no thick gravy, so think of it as a light chicken and vegetable soup. If that is what you want, Progresso’s Traditional Chicken Noodle is a more honest pick.
18. Progresso Vegetable Classics Creamy Mushroom

Progresso Vegetable Classics Creamy Mushroom is a vegetarian, ready-to-eat soup made with portabella mushrooms. Some shoppers like its smooth texture, but others say it falls short on flavor.
A common complaint is the salt. Retailer labels list about 790 to 800 mg of sodium per one-cup serving, roughly 35% of the daily value, and the can holds more than one serving.
Shoppers also say the mushroom taste can be muted. You may notice a thick, creamy base with less earthy flavor than the name suggests, and some find it heavier than they like.
For a better mushroom soup, try Pacific Foods Organic Cream of Mushroom, made with organic mushrooms and cream, and thin it with milk to your liking.
19. Campbell’s Cream of Bacon Soup

Campbell’s Condensed Cream of Bacon is a newer cooking soup, sold for casseroles and sauces. It is still on many store shelves, but shoppers who try it often say it doesn’t live up to the name.
The most common complaint is the flavor. You may expect a strong bacon taste, but reviewers often say the bacon flavor is faint, and the soup tastes more like a plain, salty cream base.
The texture draws comments too. Some say it comes out thick and pasty, and it can taste flat unless you add more ingredients.
Like most condensed soups, it is high in sodium, and the label counts a serving as only part of the can. For real bacon flavor, fry a few strips yourself and stir them into a basic white sauce or a can of cream of potato.
20. Campbell’s Cream of Celery Soup

Campbell’s Cream of Celery is rarely eaten straight from the can. Most shoppers buy it as a cooking ingredient for casseroles, gravies and slow cooker recipes, and on its own the soup does not hold up well.
Shoppers commonly describe the flavor as faint and bland. You may expect a clear celery taste, but many reviewers report a mostly salty, starchy base with only a hint of vegetable. The texture is another complaint, with the soup coming out thick and gluey rather than smooth.
Sodium is also a concern, especially when you use it as a recipe base on top of other seasoned ingredients.
If you want a better option, make a quick cream base at home with butter, flour, milk and sautéed celery, which takes only a few minutes and lets you control the salt.
21. Campbell’s Cream of Mushroom Soup

Campbell’s Cream of Mushroom is one of the best-known canned soups in the country, yet it draws mixed reactions when you eat it on its own. Shoppers often see it as a cooking ingredient first and a soup second.
The most common complaint is texture. Heated straight from the can, the soup can look gluey and thick, and some reviewers say it sets into a gel in the pot. Others point out that the mushroom pieces are small and hard to notice.
Flavor is the next issue. Many shoppers find the taste mild and salty at the same time, with a processed quality that stands out when you eat it by the bowl.
If you want an alternative for cooking, Pacific Foods Organic Cream of Mushroom is made with organic mushrooms and cream, and many shoppers find it tastes fresher and less pasty.
22. Campbell’s Cream of Chicken Soup

Campbell’s Cream of Chicken is one of the most recognizable cans in the aisle, and you have likely used it in a casserole or slow cooker recipe. Shoppers who taste it straight from the can are often less impressed.
A common complaint is the flavor. Reviewers describe it as salty and one-note, tasting more of cream and seasoning than of chicken. The texture also draws criticism, since it can come out thick and gluey.
You may also notice that the chicken pieces are tiny and hard to find. Others point to the sodium, which is high enough that people watching their intake often avoid it.
If you want a better option, Pacific Foods Organic Condensed Cream of Chicken is made with roasted chicken and cream. You could also make a simple version at home with butter, flour and chicken broth.
23. Campbell’s Well Yes! Chicken Noodle Soup

Campbell’s launched its Well Yes! line in 2017 as a more wholesome take on canned soup. The current chicken noodle version uses chicken bone broth, egg noodles and white beans, and it draws mixed reactions from shoppers who expected something noticeably better than the classic can.
Reviewers often point to texture first. The noodles can come out soft and mushy, and the chicken pieces can seem sparse. If you want a soup with some bite, you may find this one underwhelming.
Flavor is the other common complaint. Some shoppers describe the broth as mild to the point of bland, so they end up adding salt, pepper or herbs.
If you want more substance, try Progresso Traditional Chicken Noodle, which many shoppers say has a fuller broth. Pacific Foods Organic Chicken Noodle is another choice if you prefer organic ingredients.
24. Campbell’s Condensed Cheddar Cheese Soup

Campbell’s Condensed Cheddar Cheese Soup has been on shelves for decades and is often used as a shortcut in casseroles and sauces. When you eat it on its own, shoppers report a mixed experience.
The most common complaint is the flavor. You may find the cheddar taste muted and more processed than sharp, with a salty edge. Reviewers also describe the texture as thick and pasty, especially when it is mixed with water instead of milk.
Sodium is another concern. Like most condensed soups, a single can holds more than one serving, so the total climbs quickly if you eat it all.
If you want real cheese flavor, melt sharp cheddar into a simple white sauce. It takes about as long as heating the can and tastes far closer to what the label promises.
25. Campbell’s Chunky Beef with Country Vegetables

Campbell’s Chunky Beef with Country Vegetables is a familiar can in many pantries. It promises pieces of beef with potatoes, carrots and other vegetables in a thick broth.
Shoppers often find the flavor underwhelming. Several reviewers describe the broth as bland and say it lacks the depth the label suggests.
Another common complaint is the meat. You may find fewer beef pieces than the name implies, and the texture can be stringy rather than tender. Some shoppers also mention that the vegetables are mushy.
Sodium is a concern too, so check the label if you watch your intake. For a beefier bowl, Progresso Traditional Beef Barley adds diced beef, barley and carrots to a lighter broth, at about 680 mg of sodium per cup on retailer labels.
26. Campbell’s Chunky Chili Mac

Campbell’s Chunky Chili Mac combines kidney beans, macaroni, seasoned ground meat and tomatoes. On paper, it sounds like a hearty cross between chili and mac. Shoppers say the result falls short.
The most common complaint is texture. You may find the macaroni soft and the sauce thin, so the can feels more like a watery pasta soup than a thick chili. Some reviewers also report that the meat is sparse.
Flavor draws mixed reactions, from too spicy to flat and one-note. Retailer labels list about 790 mg of sodium per one-cup serving.
If you want a chili-style meal in a can, Hormel Chili with Beans offers a thicker body, and you can stir in your own cooked macaroni.
27. Campbell’s Chunky Hearty Beef Barley

Campbell’s Chunky Hearty Beef Barley is a ready-to-heat soup with beef, toasted barley, carrots and potatoes. It lands on this list mostly because it falls short for shoppers who expect a lot from the word “hearty.”
A common complaint is the beef. You may find only a few small pieces, and some shoppers describe them as dry or chewy. The barley can also turn soft and mushy after heating.
Sodium is another frequent concern. Retailer labels list about 790 mg per one-cup serving, and the can holds about two servings.
If you want a better option, try Progresso Traditional Beef Barley or Amy’s Organic Vegetable Barley. Both get more favorable comments for flavor, and Amy’s is a good meat-free choice.
28. Wolfgang Puck Organic Chicken & Egg Noodles Soup (Discontinued)

Wolfgang Puck’s organic canned soups carried a famous chef’s name and a premium price. Campbell’s bought the Wolfgang Puck soup business in 2008, and the soups have since disappeared from the market, so you will not find this can on shelves today.
While it was sold, the most common complaint was the price. It often cost several times as much as a basic can of chicken noodle, and many felt the bowl did not taste different enough to justify that.
If you want an organic chicken noodle soup today, try Pacific Foods Organic Chicken Noodle, made with organic chicken, egg noodles, carrots, celery and peas.
29. Campbell’s Chunky Savory Chicken with White & Wild Rice

Campbell’s Chunky Savory Chicken with White & Wild Rice has loyal fans, but it also draws consistent criticism. If you open a can expecting a thick, hearty bowl, you may be surprised by how much of it is broth.
Common complaints focus on texture. Some shoppers report that the rice turns soft and mushy, and the chicken pieces can seem small or stringy. The carrots and potatoes are often described as limp.
Sodium is the other frequent concern. Retailer labels list about 790 mg per one-cup serving, so check the label if you watch your salt.
If you want a similar soup with a simpler ingredient list, try Pacific Foods Organic Chicken & Wild Rice, which also comes in a lightly salted version.
30. Campbell’s Homestyle Chicken Noodle Soup

Campbell’s Homestyle Chicken Noodle Soup is meant to taste closer to something made in your own kitchen. Many shoppers say it falls short of that promise.
The most common complaint concerns the broth. You may find it thin and salty, with a flavor that comes across as flat rather than rich.
Texture is another sticking point. Shoppers often report soft, overcooked noodles and small pieces of chicken that do not look like the chunks pictured on the label. Vegetables can seem sparse too.
Some longtime buyers also say the soup tastes different from what they remember, though Campbell’s has not announced a recipe change. If you want a better can, try Progresso Traditional Chicken Noodle or Pacific Foods Organic Chicken Noodle.
